“…This dynamic is sometimes cited as evidence of increasing support for the Spanish state. It is interpreted as a manifestation of a developing civil or shared identity (Martínez-Herrera, 2002, p. 423; Muro & Quiroga, 2005, p. 24), or as evidence of the decline of exclusivist nationalisms in favor of a multinationalism or pluralism that recognizes other identities but continues to locate sovereignty in the overarching Spanish nation (Balfour & Quiroga, 2007, p. 75; Llera, 2009, p. 326; Núñez, 2001, p. 734). Almost all analyses to date share the perspective adopted by Beramendi and Máiz (2004), who argue that devolution may be considered successful “as long as we observe a robust association between the development of the EA [ Estado de las Autonomías , or State of the Autonomies], the expansion of dual identities, and the shrinking of exclusive ones” (p. 138).…”