“…The open circuit voltage (V OC ) deficit is however large compared to the structurally similar Cu(In,Ga)Se 2 (CIGS) photovoltaic devices [2,3], and is the main reason for a relatively modest record cell efficiency of 12.6% for the S, Se variant Cu 2 ZnSn (S,Se) 4 or CZTSSe [4]. A key difference between CZTS and CIGS is the extensive band tailing in the former [3,5]. Band tailing in CZTS is related to: (i) Urbach tails in absorption and quantum efficiency spectra [5], (ii) broadening of Raman vibration modes [6,7], (iii) S-shaped temperature dependence of the photoluminescence peak [8,9] and (iv) an anomalously long carrier lifetime at low temperature [3,10].…”