What predicts drug-free type 2 diabetes remission? Insights from an 8-year general practice service evaluation of a lower carbohydrate diet with weight loss

Abstract

BackgroundType 2 diabetes (T2D) is often regarded as a progressive, lifelong disease requiring an increasing number of drugs. Sustained remission of T2D is now well established, but is not yet routinely practised. Norwood surgery has used a low-carbohydrate programme aiming to achieve remission since 2013.MethodsAdvice on a lower carbohydrate diet and weight loss was offered routinely to people with T2D between 2013 and 2021, in a suburban practice with 9800 patients. Conventional ‘one-to-one’ GP consultations were used, supplemented by group consultations and personal phone calls as necessary. Those interested in participating were computer coded for ongoing audit to compare ‘baseline’ with ‘latest follow-up’ for relevant parameters.ResultsThe cohort who chose the low-carbohydrate approach (n=186) equalled 39% of the practice T2D register. After an average of 33 months median (IQR) weight fell from 97 (84–109) to 86 (76–99) kg, giving a mean (SD) weight loss of −10 (8.9)kg. Median (IQR) HbA1c fell from 63 (54–80) to 46 (42–53) mmol/mol. Remission of diabetes was achieved in 77% with T2D duration less than 1 year, falling to 20% for duration greater than 15 years. Overall, remission was achieved in 51% of the cohort. Mean LDL cholesterol decreased by 0.5 mmol/L, mean triglyceride by 0.9 mmol/L and mean systolic blood pressure by 12 mm Hg. There were major prescribing savings; average Norwood surgery spend was £4.94 per patient per year on drugs for diabetes compared with £11.30 for local practices. In the year ending January 2022, Norwood surgery spent £68 353 per year less than the area average.ConclusionsA practical primary care-based method to achieve remission of T2D is described. A low-carbohydrate diet-based approach was able to achieve major weight loss with substantial health and financial benefit. It resulted in 20% of the entire practice T2D population achieving remission. It appears that T2D duration <1 year represents an important window of opportunity for achieving drug-free remission of diabetes. The approach can also give hope to those with poorly controlled T2D who may not achieve remission, this group had the greatest improvements in diabetic control as represented by HbA1c.

Efficacy of low carbohydrate and ketogenic diets in treating mood and anxiety disorders: systematic review and implications for clinical practice

“…Finally, the effect of LC/KD on overall healthcare costs in mood disorders would also be of interest, as these costs have been shown to be reduced by LC/KD in people with type 2 diabetes. 152 …”

“…151 Finally, the effect of LC/KD on overall healthcare costs in mood disorders would also be of interest, as these costs have been shown to be reduced by LC/KD in people with type 2 diabetes. 152 This review was conducted in the context of debate around many aspects of nutrition, especially 'low carb' diets, and mounting scientific and public interest. There is a very limited and lowquality evidence base on the efficacy of KD in mood disorders.…”

Scarlett McNally: Obesity is a community issue, not just an individual one

“…The Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition already recommends low carbohydrate diets for people with type 2 diabetes 9. And real world studies of people with type 2 diabetes show that a low carbohydrate diet and moderate exercise cause significant reductions in obesity, improved blood lipid profiles, lowering of blood glycosylated haemoglobin, and higher drug-free remission rates 1011…”

Scaling group consultations – the fourth healthcare revolution: A call to action to save primary care

“…What is less readily appreciated is how many services have seamlessly transitioned group consultation care into virtual delivery, with attendant benefits. This includes agile practice‐based models, 7 whole system implementation of diabetes virtual group consultations across the whole of Northwest London Integrated Care System, but also National Health Service (NHS) programmes like the Diabetes Prevention Programme (Harry McMillan, personal communication 2022). Furthermore, several effective models for healthcare issues like menopausal symptoms and providing broader support for women's health have been developed.…”

“…This includes agile practice-based models, 7 F I G U R E 1 Ecological systems theory: Insights into (virtual) group consultation models. several effective models for healthcare issues like menopausal symptoms and providing broader support for women's health have been developed.…”