What’s in the box? Exploring UK players’ experiences of loot boxes in games; the conceptualisation and parallels with gambling

Abstract

Loot boxes are a popular mechanic within many video games, but it remains unclear if some forms of loot boxes can be seen of as gambling. However, the perspectives of players are often neglected, such as whether they see them as ‘fair’ game elements and how closely they feel this aligns with gambling. In this paper, we synthesise a conceptualisation for loot boxes through players’ actual experience and explore if there are any parallels with gambling. Twenty-one participants who played video games took part in the research through either an interview or online survey. Thematic analysis suggested that six themes were core to exploring loot boxes: Random Chance Effects, Attitudes Towards Content, Implementation, Parallels with Gambling, Game Design, and The Player. The results suggested both indirect and direct parallels with gambling from the players experiences. Implications of game design and classifying loot boxes as gambling are discussed in relation to game design and risk factors of gambling and purchasing behaviour.

The Ethics of AI in Games

“…While a few years ago loot boxes-i.e. virtual items that can be redeemed for other random items that provide some value to the players [56]-made waves [57]- [59], the new monetisation technique sweeping across the industry is the battle pass or season pass system. Unlike previous iterations of premium subscriptions, in-game currencies, downloadable content packs, loot boxes, and gated progression, the battle pass system does not promise any immediate tangible reward to players.…”

Emerging Trends in Play-to-Earn (P2E) Games

“…Another important monetization technique is setting up a socially acceptable way to play P2E games by mixing spending and non-spending players. This idea includes creating cosmetics, allowing the inspection of other players' items, and accessing leaderboards [53].…”

What Constitutes ‘Gaming’ in the Gaming Disorder?: Observations and Recommendations

“… 16 , 17 Certain arcade and casino “games” imitate different types of gambling. 18 In addition, in-game gambling has been described for different “games” such as Poker, Roulette, Blackjack, and Slot Machines. Debates are ongoing about whether gaming and gambling products can be classified based on features of playfulness, interactivity, elements of skills, planning, consideration, and achievements.…”