What would we use and how would we use it? Can digital technology be used to both enhance and evaluate well-being outcomes with highly vulnerable and disadvantaged young people?

Abstract

An increasing number of technology apps for managing wellbeing and mental health are permeating young people’s use of digital spaces. There are a range of online wellbeing tools which have been developed to promote self-tracking and build young people’s wellbeing and mental health, for example, Optimism, My Mood Tracker and Strava. Tracking outcomes of support with highly transient young people is, more broadly, a particular challenge for youth workers, evaluators and social researchers. Using digital apps to promote as well as monitor wellbeing with tech-savvy young people is an enticing prospect for youth support services, particularly with young people whose engagement with support is sporadic and unpredictable during periods of homelessness or other crisis situations. The use of purpose-designed digital apps may have the potential to not only benefit young people’s mental health and wellbeing, but also enhance the consistency and quality of their connection with support services. In principle, putting wellbeing digital tools directly into the hands, and phones, of young people who are accessing support services seems to make good sense. A great number of online resources have, however, relatively limited uptake in highly vulnerable youth populations. The design starting point must therefore be, what would they use and how would they use it? How can digital apps help to promote stronger support engagement, be aligned with young people’s perspectives and priorities of wellbeing, and enable better outcomes evaluation? This article shares learnings from a consultation with more than 400 young youth service users to build better understanding of their relationships with digital technologies, what they would use and how they would use it to better connect with support as well as to promote and record changes in wellbeing over time. Exploring the young people’s perspectives on wellbeing, service delivery and use of digital technologies has broad implications for the integration of digital technology into both service delivery and evaluation of youth programmes. The findings suggest that digital platforms can play a role in evaluating youth wellbeing over time. The prerequisites, are however, that young people’s autonomy and individuality must be supported. We need to start from a place that facilitates agency and creativity, and focuses on capturing qualitative data that meet young people in their world – even when this is challenging for us.

A Digital Intervention to Improve Mental Health and Interpersonal Resilience in Young People Who Have Experienced Technology-Assisted Sexual Abuse: Protocol for a Nonrandomized Feasibility Clinical Trial and Nested Qualitative Study

“…The user-driven design approach we have adopted in this trial is intended to ensure that the intervention is engaging and relevant and reflects the experiences of YP-TASA. For example, Vichta et al [ 37 ] used interactive workshops and a web-based survey to gather YP’s perspectives on platform integration into mental health care. Venning et al [ 38 ] conducted semistructured interviews and focus groups to explore the acceptability of a low-intensity digital computer-based training platform incorporating a virtual coach with university students and HCPs.…”

Evaluation of the Use of Digital Mental Health Platforms and Interventions: Scoping Review

“…Although the evidence synthesis found more of a focus on adults, there was a slightly higher number of targeted strategies for young people. However, there is a need for more effective qualitative strategies such as in designing and implementing youth-oriented tailored solutions [68] and implementing a centralized DMH platform to improve stakeholder accessibility [74]. The previous review of Spadaro et al [51] suggested overhauling the application of codesign, behavior theories, and clinical evaluation.…”

“…One mixed-methods study on feasibility found DMH platforms can assist evaluating youth wellbeing [68]. However, more effective qualitative strategies are required.…”

Role of Social and App-Related Factors in Behavioral Engagement With mHealth for Improved Well-being Among Chronically Ill Patients: Scenario-Based Survey Study

“…The behavioral engagement of patients with health care technologies has been associated with improved well-being [ 8 , 38 , 39 ]. As widely acknowledged in the well-being literature [ 18 ], well-being incorporates hedonic well-being, with its focus on pleasure attainment, and eudaemonic well-being, with its focus on self-realization, that is, the degree to which a person is fully functioning.…”