When I becomes we

Abstract

When I becomes we: how prototypically 'pop' are a band's lyrics after one breakup and two reunions? AbstractThis study investigates how the two Take That reunions are reflected in their song lyrics and how this marks a noticeable step away from discourse styles traditionally associated with pop song lyrics. Previous studies have shown pop song lyrics to exhibit a set of prototypical features such as high frequencies of the words you, I, and love, which has often led to the conclusion that pop lyrics are usually perceived as highly clichéd and based on a limited set of stereotypical metaphors. Based on a quantitative and qualitative analysis, this article will show that while Take That's lyrics of the early years are very much in line with this description, they have since undergone some substantial changes with regard to their 'prototypicality' as pop lyrics. In line with the band's own new self-description as a group rather than five individuals, it will be shown that from the first reunion onwards, new participants have been introduced into the discourse (we, they), which are otherwise rare in pop lyrics. This change comes with a variety of new attributes, roles and metaphors, which have moved their lyrics away from prototypical pop music discourse. This study also aims to stress the potential of a linguistic, specifically a corpus-linguistic, approach to the genre of pop song lyrics. It will be argued that such an approach can reveal important developments in the overall structure of a text collection that can hint at substantial changes in the underlying discourse that might otherwise pass unnoticed.

Songs you know by heart

“…In each instance, the authors examined either convenience samples on internet fan websites (Bowen 1997;Mihelich and Papineau 2005) or handpicked songs to exemplify the authors' arguments (Bowen 1997;Ingersoll 2001). Indeed, systematically examining an artist's lyrics in their entirety is quite rare (Hilbert 2012), yet understanding how musicians develop throughout their careers is an important endeavor (Collins 2012;Punter 2014). The current research examines some of the same issues as these previous researchers as well as additional questions through systematically content analyzing all of Jimmy Buffett's song lyrics.…”