When the solution is part of the problem: problem solving in elderly suicide attempters

Abstract

SUMMARYObjectives-Depression, loss, and physical illness are associated with suicide in the elderly. However, the nature of individual vulnerability remains poorly understood. Poor problem solving has been suggested as a risk factor for suicide in younger adults. Unresolved problems may create an accumulation of stressors. Thus, those with perceived deficits in problem-solving ability may be predisposed to suicidal behavior. To test this hypothesis, we investigated whether elderly suicide attempters perceived their problem solving as deficient.Methods-Sixty-four individuals aged 60 and older participated in the study including depressed suicide attempters, depressed non-attempters, and non-depressed controls. The social problem solving inventory-revised: short-version was used to measure participants' perceived social problem solving, assessing both adaptive problem-solving dimensions (positive problem orientation and rational problem solving) and dysfunctional dimensions (negative problem orientation, impulsivity/carelessness, and avoidance).Results-Depressed elderly who had attempted suicide perceived their overall problem solving as deficient, compared to non-suicidal depressed and non-depressed elderly. Suicide attempters perceived their problems more negatively and approached them in a more impulsive manner. On rational problem solving and avoidant style sub-scales, suicide attempters did not differ from nonsuicidal depressed. However, both depressed groups reported lower rational problem solving and higher avoidance compared to non-depressed controls.Conclusions-A perception of life problems as threatening and unsolvable and an impulsive approach to problem solving appear to predispose vulnerable elderly to suicide attempts.

Problem-Solving Therapy Reduces Suicidal Ideation In Depressed Older Adults with Executive Dysfunction

“…Deficits in problem solving abilities are particularly pronounced in older adults with a history of suicide attempts compared to depressed older adults and non-depressed older adults[14, 39, 40]. We have shown that PST is effective for treating depression[19], disability associated with depression[20] and mild cognitive impairments[21], three major risk factors for suicide risk in older adults.…”

Suicide in older people: Revisioning new approaches

“…In some individuals who die by suicide, there is no mental illness detected prior to suicide (De Gioannis & De Leo 2012;Pridmore 2011). However, the assessment and treatment of depression is largely recognized as the key tenet of elderly suicide prevention (Wiktorsson et al 2011) and research, as evidenced by numerous studies (Bergman Levy et al 2011;Conwell & Duberstein 2005;Gibbs et al 2009;Minayo & Cavalcante 2010;Miyabayashi 2002;Takahashi et al 1995;Tsoh et al 2005). Social work participants in Kim's (2013) study expressed deep concern about the 'overemphasis on depression as a primary cause of elderly suicide', describing the 'medical framing of elderly suicide' as a barrier to intervention:…”

Suicide in Older Adults: The Role of Emotions and Cognition

“…Lack of feeling connected to others [84] and poor social problem solving [85] can amplify the risk for suicide. Szanto and colleagues reported that older suicide attempters committed significantly more errors in social emotion recognition and showed poorer global cognitive performance than elders with no psychiatric history [86].…”