Where there is no policy: governing the posting and transfer of primary health care workers in Nigeria

Abstract

SummaryThe posting and transfer of health workers and managers receives little policy and research attention in global health. In Nigeria, there is no national policy on posting and transfer in the health sector. We sought to examine how the posting and transfer of frontline primary health care (PHC) workers is conducted in four states (Lagos, Benue, Nasarawa and Kaduna) across Nigeria, where public sector PHC facilities are usually the only form of formal health care service providers available in many communities. We conducted in‐depth interviews with PHC workers and managers, and group discussions with community health committee members. The results revealed three mechanisms by which PHC managers conduct posting and transfer: (1) periodically moving PHC workers around as a routine exercise aimed at enhancing their professional experience and preventing them from being corrupted; (2) as a tool for improving health service delivery by assigning high‐performing PHC workers to PHC facilities perceived to be in need, or posting PHC workers nearer their place of residence; and (3) as a response to requests for punishment or favour from PHC workers, political office holders, global health agencies and community health committees. Given that posting and transfer is conducted by discretion, with multiple influences and sometimes competing interests, we identified practices that may lead to unfair treatment and inequities in the distribution of PHC workers. The posting and transfer of PHC workers therefore requires policy measures to codify what is right about existing informal practices and to avert their negative potential. © 2016 The Authors The International Journal of Health Planning and Management Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd

Implementation of the free maternity services policy and its implications for health system governance in Kenya

“…9 Abimbola et al adapted the multilevel framework developed by Ostrom 10 to assess governance of primary healthcare in Nigeria. [10][11][12][13] Furthermore, Abimbola et al used the concept of transaction costs originally developed by Williamson (1979) to explore the barriers to accessing tuberculosis services in Nigeria. 14 Other examples of institutional analysis can be found in our recent systematic review of frameworks for assessing health system governance.…”

Effectiveness of the Diagnose-Intervene- Verify-Adjust (DIVA) model for integrated primary healthcare planning and performance improvement: an embedded mixed methods evaluation in Kaduna state, Nigeria

“…However, most efforts to address them have focused on increasing their numbers and distribution, particularly Community Health Extension Workers 44. This approach is not unusual in LMICs given that maldistribution and high attrition rates are common human resource challenges in these countries 45. For example, maldistribution of health workers following punitive transfers and lobbying for posting are common concerns that have affected equitable access of clients to services in India, Pakistan, Mali and Kenya, which staff audits and re-distribution have attempted to solve 33–36.…”

Promoting anti-corruption, transparency and accountability in the recruitment and promotion of health workers to safeguard health outcomes

“…Abimbola et al's study in Nigeria reported that HRH management decisions in the health service were sometimes based on requests for favours from health workers and politicians. In addition, lobbying powerful political intermediaries could be used by health workers to reverse a decision they deemed unfavourable [37]. Karakose's study in Turkey interviewed doctors on their views on favouritism and reported that unfairness in appointing managers based on their political and ideological views was common [38].…”

“…Cronyism means, 'the appointment of friends and associates to positions of authority, without proper regard to their qualifications,' [42]. Studies that have considered nepotism and cronyism in the health sector include Abimbola's study on Nigeria referred to above, which reported that Senior Medical Personnel personalized appointments outside formal procedures and without clear criteria, 'because of gratitude or friendship' [37]. This sometimes resulted in the recruitment of persons who displayed signs of incompetency.…”