Why Are High-Achieving Students Susceptible to Inhibition? An Idiographic Analysis of Student Self-Identity in China

Abstract

High-achieving students face greater expectations in competitive societies such as China, which can impede their performance. Based on previous observations regarding what we call the “inhibition phenomenon of high-achieving students,” wherein otherwise successful students show unexpectedly poor performances in collective activities of relatively unfamiliar forms, the present research analyzes the self-identity of such students and explores the underlying mechanisms that result in this inhibition phenomenon. An idiographic approach is employed to examine typical cases and their semiotic mediation in the self-identity regulative process. Two high-achieving students who exhibit the characteristics of the inhibition phenomenon are compared with another high-achieving student who appears not to be inhibited, using a multilevel and comprehensive analysis that integrates a number of aspects, such as the students’ emotional experience of the activities in relation to which the inhibition phenomenon occurs, their meaning-making regarding the activities, and their reflections on their daily school lives. The findings show that, for the inhibited students, a cued identity as being a “good student” is activated through the activities with the connotations of “being successful compared to the others” and “pursuing recognition” leading to a worsened performance; alternatively, the student not susceptible to inhibition displays an identity of being a “learner,” who focuses on the content of the activity and concrete suggestions from important others. These specific semiotic mediation processes indicate that, when self-identity is narrow and result oriented, it is easy for excessive future-oriented self-demands to be imposed, thereby bringing pressure to the individual at that moment. By contrast, a flexible and process-oriented identity facilitates an individual’s involvement in unfamiliar activities, enabling a richer, more open self-construction process.

Self-Identity and Career Success of Nurses in Infectious Disease Department: The Chain-Mediating Effects of Cognitive Emotion Regulation and Social Support

“…Self-identity Scale Self-identity was measured by the Self-identity Scale (SIS), which was compiled by psychologists Ochse and Plug according to Eriksson's theory (Ochse and Plug, 1986). The scale has been translated and debugged into a Chinese version by scholars and has been widely used in China with good reliability and validity (Qasim et al, 2019;Wu et al, 2019). There are 19 items on the scale, such as "I am proud of being a member of the group" and "my value is recognized by others."…”

Adolescents' loneliness and problematic smartphone use: The mediating role of upward social comparison and the moderating role of self‐identity

“…Each item was rated on a 4‐point Likert scale (1 = strongly disagree to 4 = strongly agree ). The scale has good reliability and validity and has been widely used in China (Wu et al, 2019, 2020). A low score indicates a less developed self‐identity.…”

Improving Learning Engagement Among Ethnic Minority High School Students in China Through School-Based Social Support: An Intervention Study

“…China's current test-oriented education system is characterized by the college entrance examination, where assessment is primarily presented through ranking and grading to select students. Consequently, students, particularly those constantly pursuing outstanding academic achievements, often need a sense of self-identity [35] . During the activity, students assumed various corresponding responsibilities and worked collaboratively in groups to complete the assigned tasks.…”