Why are rural Indian women so thin? Findings from a village in Maharashtra

Abstract

Objective: To identify social, behavioural and cultural factors that explain the thinness of young women relative to their men in rural Maharashtra, India. Design: Twelve focus group discussions were conducted to explore the villagers' understanding of why women in their area might be thinner than men. Setting: Pabal village and surrounding hamlets, in the Pune district of Maharashtra, India. Subjects: Samples of young mothers and fathers, grandmothers and grandfathers were selected from families in the village with children below 10 years of age. Results: Four factors were identified that the villagers felt contributed to the disparity in thinness. First, marriage isolated girls from their own families and villages, and brought the expectation of early motherhood. Young brides were often unable to relax and eat adequately. Second, marriage increased the workload of young women. They were expected to do the heaviest household chores as well as farm work in this predominantly agricultural community. Third, women had no financial autonomy or freedom of movement, and were therefore denied access to supplementary food sources available to men. Fourth, young women felt responsible for their household's health and success. They were encouraged to fast regularly to ensure this. Despite feeling responsible, young women had no control over factors that might affect the household's well being. This made them anxious and worried a great deal of the time. Conclusions: Interventions to improve the nutritional status of young women in this region need to recognise the roles and responsibilities taken up by young brides.

Gender Difference in Care of Type 2 Diabetes

“…This is the picture of the developing world where women neglect their own health. 18 Social roles prevent women from practicing exercise. They have no time from their work.…”

Women’s Marriage Age Matters for Public Health: A Review of the Broader Health and Social Implications in South Asia

“…For example, a cross-sectional survey from 2001 to 2003 of 3,000 women aged 18–45 years in Goa, India found indicators of gender disadvantage such as an early age at marriage and childbearing, low levels of decision-making autonomy, family support, and sexual violence by husbands increased the prevalence of mixed-anxiety depressive disorder ( 102 ). Another qualitative sub-study of the rural Pune Maternal Nutrition Study conducted 12 separate focus group discussions with young mothers and fathers, grandmothers and grandfathers in 1998 ( 103 ). It found that young mothers had poor nutritional status and experienced anxiety and depression because their minimal influence over the allocation of resources restricted access to health services, and social isolation prevented them from caring for their children’s health and education.…”

Gender Differences in Body Mass Index in Rural India Are Determined by Socio-Economic Factors and Lifestyle

“…Between 1994 and1996, a study of women living in villages near Pune city in western India was carried out to examine the relationship of maternal nutrition to fetal growth (4-6). The study showed that thinner women had thinner babies, and also found women to be significantly thinner than their husbands (7); 65% of women had body mass indices (BMIs) below 18.5 kg/m 2 , an indicator of chronic energy deficiency, compared with 39% of their husbands.…”

“…Though it seems likely that this role affects women’s nutritional status, there is little direct evidence to link the two. Villagers in rural Maharashtra believed their women were thin because of the combined demands of early motherhood and work (7). This paper describes an attempt to identify the social and economic correlates of thinness among young women in this population (the first survey), and to explore how women’s daily activities might contribute to this phenomenon (the second survey).…”