Why are the poor less covered in Ghana’s national health insurance? A critical analysis of policy and practice

Abstract

BackgroundThe National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS) was introduced in Ghana to ensure equity in healthcare access. Presently, some low and middle income countries including Ghana are using social health insurance schemes to reduce inequity in access to healthcare. In Ghana, the NHIS was introduced to address the problem of inequity in healthcare access in a period that was characterised by user-fee regimes. The premium is heavily subsidised and exemption provided for the poorest, yet studies reveal that they are least enrolled in the scheme. We used a multi-level perspective as conceptual and methodological tool to examine why the NHIS is not reaching the poor as envisaged.MethodsFifteen communities in the Central and Eastern Regions of Ghana were surveyed after implementing a 20 months intervention programme aimed at ensuring that community members have adequate knowledge of the NHIS’ principles and benefits and improve enrolment and retention rates. Observation and in-depth interviews were used to gather information about the effects of the intervention in seven selected communities, health facilities and District Health Insurance Schemes in the Central Region.ResultsThe results showed a distinct rise in the NHIS’ enrolment among the general population but the poor were less covered. Of the 6790 individuals covered in the survey, less than half (40.3 %) of the population were currently insured in the NHIS and 22.4 % were previously insured. The poorest had the lowest enrolment rate: poorest 17.6 %, poor 31.3 %, rich 46.4 % and richest 44.4 % (p = 0.000). Previous enrolment rates were: poorest (15.4 %) and richest (23.8 %), (p = 0.000). Ironically, the poor’s low enrolment was widely attributed to their poverty. The underlying structural cause, however, was policy makers’ and implementers’ lack of commitment to pursue NHIS’ equity goal.ConclusionInequity in healthcare access persists because of the social and institutional environment in which the NHIS operates. There is a need to effectively engage stakeholders to develop interventions to ensure that the poor are included in the NHIS.

Health insurance coverage and access to skilled birth attendance in Togo

“…This finding seems to contradict the postulated hypothesis that the newly introduced public insurance scheme will provide more coverage for women of low socioeconomic status than for their well‐off counterparts, and challenges the underlying assumption that the insurance scheme will foster healthcare access equity. In agreement with the present results, studies conducted in Ghana showed less national health insurance coverage among the poor. The disparity in insurance coverage by wealth status indicates that Togo is lagging in addressing the importance of insurance in protecting against health‐related financial risks among the poor.…”

Challenges toward achieving universal health coverage in Ghana, Kenya, Nigeria, and Tanzania

“…This is especially so due to the fact that the law requires that the poor who will qualify for premium exemption be homeless. In the extended family culture of Ghana, homelessness almost does not exist as the very poor normally live in family houses, with friends, or in dilapidated houses …”

The path to longer and healthier lives for all Africans by 2030: the Lancet Commission on the future of health in sub-Saharan Africa

“…Despite the insurance enrolment camps, heavy subsidisation, and exemptions from contributions, the poor are still at least twice less likely to be enrolled in Ghana's NHIS than the rich. 162 This is partially due to policy incoherence e.g. one of the stipulated criteria to identify the core poor is not having a fixed place of residence, which is only rarely the case and in effect disqualifies many of the poor.…”