Why Do Cities Grow? Insights from Nonequilibrium Thermodynamics at the Urban and Global Scales

Abstract

SummaryThis forum article explores thermodynamic understanding of the growth of cities, including theoretical foundations, observations, and analysis. The general theory of nonequilibrium thermodynamics is reviewed, recognizing differences in interpretation between Prigogine and Schneider and Kay as well as discussing the hypothesis of maximum entropy production. Calculations of exergy gradients in a few cities and settlements, along with measures of anthropogenic heat loss in further cities, support the notion that cities are dissipative structures. The observation that primary energy use per capita increases in Singapore and Hong Kong as they grow is further evidence to support the thermodynamic understanding of the growth of cities, indicative of an increasing rate of entropy production. At the global scale, the strong linear relationship between global urban population and total global energy use, and the distribution of city sizes according to Zipf's law, can be understood as emergent results based on thermodynamics. Parallel results might be derived from models that represent underlying microscale processes, several of which are reviewed. Issues for future research include: development of nonequilibrium thermodynamic models specific to city growth; further study of exergy flows of cities with consistent methodology, including attention to solar energy exchanges in cities; and further exploration of links between thermodynamic and economic models of urban growth.

Energy and material flows of megacities

“…From 1900-2011, the world's urban population grew from 220 million (13% of the world's population) to 3,530 million (52% of the world's population) (1,2). This phenomenon of urbanization has prompted the development of a science of cities (3,4), including interdisciplinary contributions on scaling laws (5,6), networks (7), and the thermodynamics of cities (8,9). The growth of cities also has been strongly linked to global challenges of environmental sustainability, making the study of urban energy and material flows, e.g., for determining greenhouse gas emissions from cities and urban resource efficiency (10)(11)(12)(13)(14)(15)(16)(17)(18)(19), important.…”

Complexity in Industrial Ecology: Models, Analysis, and Actions

“…The third group of articles deals with urban systems, which has long been a focal area of IE. Bristow and Kennedy () explore how thermodynamics can inform and characterize the growth of cities. They frame cities as systems that grow because they are dissipative structures, where order is created and held by importing negative entropy from the city surroundings.…”

Efficiency and irreversibility of movements in a city

“…The science of city is mainly devoted to the application of concepts and methods of complex systems to cities [6][7][8][9]. A city is indeed an adaptive dynamical system which grows in size and population, and consumes energy to maintain its function and structure [10][11][12][13][14].…”