Purpose
To compare early literacy of 4- and 5-year-old uncorrected hyperopic
children with that of emmetropic children.
Design
Cross-sectional.
Subjects
Children attending preschool or kindergarten who had not previously
worn refractive correction.
Methods
Cycloplegic refraction was used to identify hyperopia (≥3.0D
to ≤6.0D in most hyperopic meridian of at least one eye,
astigmatism≤1.5D, anisometropia≤1.0D) or emmetropia
(hyperopia ≤1.0D; astigmatism, anisometropia, and myopia<1.0D).
Threshold visual acuity and cover testing ruled out amblyopia or strabismus.
Accommodative response, binocular near visual acuity (VA), and near
stereoacuity were measured.
Main Outcome Measures
Trained examiners administered the Test of Preschool Early Literacy
(TOPEL), composed of Print Knowledge, Definitional Vocabulary, and
Phonological Awareness subtests.
Results
Four hundred ninety-two children (244 hyperopes and 248 emmetropes)
participated (mean age 58 months; mean±SD of the most hyperopic
meridian +3.78D±0.81 in hyperopes and
+0.51D±0.48 in emmetropes). After adjustment for age,
race/ethnicity, and parent/caregiver’s education, the mean
difference between hyperopes and emmetropes was −4.3
(p=0.01) for TOPEL overall, −2.4 (p=0.007) for Print
Knowledge, −1.6 (p=0.07) for Definitional Vocabulary, and
−0.3 (p=0.39) for Phonological Awareness. Greater deficits
in TOPEL scores were observed in hyperopic children with ≥4.0D than
emmetropes (−6.8, p=0.01 for total score; −4.0,
p=0.003 for print knowledge). The largest deficits in TOPEL scores
were observed in hyperopic children with binocular near VA of 20/40 or worse
(−8.5, p=0.002 for total score; −4.5,
p=0.001 for Print Knowledge; −3.1, p=0.04 for
Definitional Vocabulary) or near stereoacuity of 240 seconds of arc or worse
(−8.6, p<0.001 for total score; −5.3, p<0.001 for
Print Knowledge) as compared to emmetropic children.
Conclusions
Uncorrected hyperopia ≥ 4.0D or hyperopia ≥3.0 to
≤6.0D associated with reduced binocular near VA (20/40 or worse) or
reduced near stereoacuity (240 seconds of arc or worse) in 4- to 5-year-old
children enrolled in preschool or kindergarten is associated with
significantly worse performance on a test of early literacy.