Why do Some Countries Publish More Than Others? An International Comparison of Research Funding, English Proficiency and Publication Output in Highly Ranked General Medical Journals

Abstract

National factor(s) influencing publication output in the highest ranked medical journals are largely unknown. We sought to examine the relationship between national research funding and English proficiency on publication output. We identified all original research articles appearing in the five highest ranked general medical journals between 1997 and 2001. Using the country of the corresponding author as the source nation for each article, we determined a standardized publication rate across developed nations. We used multiple regression techniques to determine the influence of national expenditures on research and scores from the Test of English as a Foreign Language (TOEFL), a surrogate for English proficiency, on publication output. There was a significant relationship of national spending on research and TOEFL scores to publication output of developed countries (p = 0.04; p < 0.01, respectively). These two variables explained approximately 71.5% of the variation in publication rate across developed nations around the world (R = 0.85; p < 0.01). Normalized for population size, English-speaking nations and certain northern European countries such as Denmark, The Netherlands, Switzerland, and Sweden had the highest rate of publication in the five highest ranked general medical journals, while Asian countries had generally low rates of publication. Research spending and English proficiency were strongly associated with publication output in the highest ranked general medical journals. While these data cannot be considered definitive due to their observational nature, they do suggest that for English-language medical journals, research funding and English proficiency may be important determinants of publication.

Publish (in English) or perish: The effect on citation rate of using languages other than English in scientific publications

“…For example, Brazilian researchers with good English writing abilities outperform those with poor ones in terms of published papers, number of citations, and h-indices (Vasconcelos et al 2008). On a global comparison, English proficiency is a good predictor of publication output in top medical journals, even more than total research spending (Man et al 2004). Thus, at all levels, from individuals to countries, NES countries have an advantage over non-NES, especially over those with poor English training.…”

Representation of Developing Countries in Orthopaedic Journals: A Survey of Four Influential Orthopaedic Journals

“…Obstacles to publication may be numerous. English language proficiency [16,34] or the discretion of journals to publish material deemed to be important and appeal to the primary reader base [27] might have a large impact on successful publication. The need for orthopaedic research from the developing world cannot be understated given the well-documented increasing burden of disease.…”

Trends and potential cautions in food web research from a bibliometric analysis

“…The prevalence of English not only limits the spread of science to non-English countries, but also prohibits these countries' communication with the rest of the world. For example, Man et al (2004) found that there is a significant relationship between national spending on research and TOEFL (Test of English as a Foreign Language, a measure of English proficiency) scores with the publication output of developed countries in highly ranked general medical journals.…”