Why ethnicity and gender matters for fertility intention among married young people: a baseline evaluation from a gender transformative intervention in rural India

Abstract

BackgroundSocial inequities in early child bearing persist among young married people, especially among tribal populations in India. Rural women belonging to tribal groups and those coming from poor households are more likely to give birth before age 18. This paper explores the connection between ethnicity, gender and early fertility intention among young married people in rural India.MethodsThe data is drawn from a cross sectional baseline evaluation of an intervention programme in rural India. A sample of 273 married young people was taken. Respondents were selected using systematic random sampling. Logistic Regression was used to assess the effect of being a tribal on early fertility intention and also to determine if covariates associated with early fertility intention differed by tribal status. Qualitative data was analysed using deductive content analysis approach.ResultsBivariate and logistic regression results indicated that young married people from tribal communities had higher odds of planning a child within one year of marriage than non-tribals (OR = 1.47, p-value-0.079). Findings further suggest that early fertility intention among tribals is driven by gender factors and higher education and among non-tribals, higher education and awareness on contraception are key predictors. Among tribals, the odds of planning a child within one year of marriage was strongly associated with inequitable gender norms (OR = 1.94, p-value-0.002). Higher education showed significant positive association with non-tribals (OR = 0.19, p-value-0.014) and positive association with tribals (OR = 0.56, p-value-0.416). Qualitative investigation confirms that fertility desires of young married people are strongly influenced by gender norms especially among tribal populations.ConclusionEarly child bearing was underpinned by complex ethnic factors and gender norms. Preference for early child bearing was seen most among tribal communities. Gender attitudes were a cause of concern especially among tribal groups. These results suggest that efforts to improve early child birth will require changing gender norms related to fertility among tribals as well as social equity issues including higher education among non-tribals and tribals.

Pattern of contraceptive use, determinants and fertility intentions among tribal women in Kerala, India: a cross-sectional study

“…The primary reason for low contraceptive use may be the low access to contraceptive knowledge and services as observed in Maharashtra and Tamil Nadu 21 24. Other reasons could be early marriage, childbearing observed among tribal groups in Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan25 which was in turn associated with low contraceptive use11 and lower education 24. Other studies in central India and Nepal substantiated the role of women and husbands’ education, age of women and number of surviving boys in the use of any modern method of contraception 5 26.…”

Gender Equity Perceptions Among School-Going Adolescents: A Mixed-Methods Comparison Amongst Tribal and Non-Tribal Rural Areas of an Eastern State in India

“…The findings are similar to what Walia et al, in their study conducted in a rural area of North India, concluded about men's participation and dominance in reproductive decision making (Walia et al, 2021). The social norms and role-stereotyping of genders have been documented similarly by researchers in India and abroad, emphasizing tribal and disadvantaged populations (Khanna et al, 2018;Willan et al, 2020). Keynejad et al reported their young respondents' perception of gender-based violence being a major cause for concern (Keynejad et al, 2018).…”

Modern Contraceptive Use Among Women in Need of Family Planning in India: an Analysis of the Inequalities Related to the Mix of Methods Used

“…There is an ongoing fear of side effects and health issues associated with the use of different SARC and LARC methods (17). Additionally, research on contraceptive use in India suggests that familial pressure, as well as gender and social norms, play a strong role and that these norms have shifted little over time (17)(18)(19). Many women do not use contraception following marriage in order to demonstrate their fertility, and as a result of pressure from husbands, in-laws and communities (20)(21)(22).…”