Why first-level heatlh workers fail to follow guidelines for managing severe disease in children in the Coast Region, the United Republic of Tanzania

Abstract

Objective To determine why health workers fail to follow integrated management of childhood illness (IMCI) guidelines for severely ill children at first-level outpatient health facilities in rural areas of the United Republic of Tanzania. Methods Retrospective and prospective case reviews of severely ill children aged < 5 years were conducted at health facilities in four districts. We ascertained treatment and examined the characteristics associated with referral, conducted follow-up interviews with parents of severely ill children, and gave health workers questionnaires and interviews. Findings In total, 502 cases were reviewed at 62 facilities. Treatment with antimalarials and antibiotics was consistent with the diagnosis given by health workers. However, of 240 children classified as having "very severe febrile disease", none received all IMCIrecommended therapies, and only 25% of severely ill children were referred. Lethargy and anaemia diagnoses were independently associated with referral. Most (91%) health workers indicated that certain severe conditions can be managed without referral. Conclusion The health workers surveyed rarely adhered to IMCI treatment and referral guidelines for children with severe illness. They administered therapy based on narrow diagnoses rather than IMCI classifications, disagreed with referral guidelines and often considered referral unnecessary. To improve implementation of IMCI, attention should focus on the reasons for health worker nonadherence.Une traduction en français de ce résumé figure à la fin de l'article. Al final del artículo se facilita una traducción al español.

Evaluating the impact of pulse oximetry on childhood pneumonia mortality in resource-poor settings

“…One of these was the lack of country-specific data to inform our parameter for access to hospital care. We assumed that 61% of people who were referred to hospital would access hospital care, based on data from a retrospective case review study of children with severe pneumonia in Tanzania 24 . More realistically, we know that the proportion of children reaching an appropriate health facility may vary significantly between countries and so having one single parameter for all countries could result in inaccurate estimates.…”

National implementation of Integrated Management of Childhood Illness (IMCI): Policy constraints and strategies

“…One study in Tanzania found that only 25% of severely ill children seen at rural health facilities with IMCI-trained HCW's were referred [28]. Over 50% of HCW's indicated that they manage severe malaria and severe pneumonia in a rural health facility without referral, and that they are confident in their ability to manage severely ill children who do not have severe anemia, severe dehydration, or difficulty breathing.…”

“…As a result, many HCW's prefer to follow the IMCI algorithms from memory, and compliance with algorithms appears to decrease several weeks following training [25,28]. While there are many potential interventions that could improve HCW compliance, current literature has not yielded many clear evidence-based solutions.…”

Evaluation of IMNCI Practices among Health Care Providers in a District of North India.

“…A study in Tanzania also showed poor adherence to IMCI guidelines for managing under-five children after IMCI training. 7 A community based study conducted in Rajasthan quoted that after IMCI training given to doctors in intervention area, 15% of intervention group mothers and 10% of control group mothers sought care from an appropriate provider promptly; one month after training, intervention site doctors counselled more effectively than control group doctors, but at six months their performance had declined 8. Our previous study also showed that the HSPs knowledge and skills was improved immediately after IMNCI training but it was declined over a period of time 9,10 . With respect to general dangers sign more than half of the mothers (55.4%) were explained about the 3-5 general dangers signs like lethargy or unconscious, inability to feed /drink, vomiting everything, convulsion by HSPs.…”