Why is this happening to me? Illness beliefs held by haredi Jewish breast cancer patients: an exploratory study

Abstract

Cultural factors influence how cancer patients interpret their illness. This paper explores the meanings haredi (strictly orthodox) Jewish breast cancer patients give to their illness. In‐depth interviews were conducted with five haredi breast cancer patients. The full transcripts were subjected to interpretive phenomenological analysis. Participants' interpretations of their cancer were strongly influenced by their religious beliefs. Two interwoven themes emerged: the cancer came from God as part of a meaningful plan; the disease was a test. The implications these beliefs may have for healthcare behaviour in this group are discussed. Copyright © 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

‘We are (not) the master of our body’: elderly Jewish women's attitudes towards euthanasia and assisted suicide

“…Moreover, they must realise that giving attention to a patient's religious or ideological identity may not be restricted to offering spiritual guidance. Indeed, religion and world view might play an important influential role in dealing with illness and making concrete medical decisions (at the end of life) (Carmel and Mutran 1997, Leichtentritt and Rettig 1999, Ejaz 2000, Musgrave et al 2001, Margalith et al 2003, Wenger and Carmel 2004, DeKeyser Ganz and Musgrave 2006, Coleman et al 2007, ColemanBrueckheimer et al 2009, Gielen et al 2009b.…”

Orthodox Jewish perspectives on withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining treatment

“…This is also clear from several empirical studies conducted among (Jewish) medical practitioners [1][2][3][4][5] and (Jewish) patients and elderly. [6][7][8][9][10] Thus, the importance of religion and worldview in health care extends beyond merely spiritual care. Their significant influential role in concrete treatment decisions should be taken into account by contemporary clinical practice, particularly because it is all the more confronted with religious and cultural diversity.…”

‘There is a Time to be Born and a Time to Die’ (Ecclesiastes 3:2a): Jewish Perspectives on Euthanasia

“…They point correctly to the importance of training of healthcare professionals “in communication skills and cross-cultural medicine” (Jotkowitz 2010b ), a requirement which is indispensable given the multicultural and multireligious outlook of contemporary societies. Indeed, religion and world view have influence on the way people deal with illness and ethical dilemmas, for instance in health care (Gielen et al 2009 ; Coleman et al 2007 ; Wenger and Carmel 2004 ; DeKeyser Ganz and Musgrave 2006 ; Margalith et al 2003 ; Musgrave et al 2001 ; Ejaz 2000 ; Leichtentritt and Rettig 1999 ; Carmel and Mutran 1997 ). Consequently, hospitals’ need felt to deal with a culturally diverse patient population is high, which is clear from the steady inquiries to our center 1 to provide training and clear guidelines in this regard.…”