Windstorm Impacts on Forest-Related Socio-Ecological Systems: An Analysis from a Socio-Economic and Institutional Perspective

Abstract

Windstorms are considered among the most impacting natural events for European forests and related Socio-Ecological Systems (SES). Given that their intensity and frequency are increasing, an in-depth understanding of their impacts is crucial to mitigate risks and potential negative effects. However, so far, scientific research on windstorm impacts has mainly focused on environmental dimensions, while socio-economic and institutional ones are rarely taken into consideration. Our analysis aims at enriching the current scientific knowledge on windstorm impacts on forest SES by providing an overview of the state-of-the-art academic investigations on windstorm impacts on socio-economic and institutional dimensions. Overall, 46 papers were reviewed to identify the most recurrent post-windstorm dynamics and drivers that influence resilience and adaptation of socio-economic, institutional and related governance dimensions of European forest SES. Results show that the current scientific knowledge on socio-economic impacts of windstorms mainly concentrates on forest-related stakeholders and sectors, paying little attention to the broader social, cultural and institutional drivers that contribute to forest SES resilience. Further, cascade effects linking environmental, social and institutional dimensions are poorly analyzed. This restricted focus could lead to an incomplete understanding of the dynamics shaping socio-economic adaptability to windstorms, affecting long-term and sustainable recovery from extreme natural events. To correctly frame effective, intersectoral and coordinated recovery strategies gaining a deeper understanding of human–environment interactions is needed, as well as acknowledging the positive influence of causal relationships in improving forest-related SES resilience.

Using Choice Experiments as a Planning Tool for Reforestation after Extreme Events: The Case of the Vaia Windstorm in Italy

“…This implies that often public owners are in charge of the formulation of post-disturbance recovery plans, while private owners are usually supported with subsidies to implement such plans. Subsidies are justified by the fact that reforestation strategies, along with guaranteeing the restoration of the damaged area, "should also ensure the provision of a broad range of ecosystem services of public and community interested, combining timber production with services that meet societal and environmental demands" [48]. Again, the wide range of ecosystem services provided by forests to the local communities and recreationists, along with the use of public funding in post-disaster restoration, is a further aspect that supports the inclusions of public preferences into expert reforestation planning.…”

Brazilian Forest-Based Sector Perceptions and Contributions to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)—Developing Strategies Using the Strategic Options Development and Analysis (SODA) Approach

“…In forests, ecological and environmental functions coexist and are influenced by human needs, making them complex socio-ecological systems (SES). Nevertheless, over the past few decades, a number of factors, including an increase in the frequency and intensity of disturbances, such as extreme weather events, have contributed to the heightened activation of these systems and the various services they offer [18]. The global forest sector is becoming increasingly cross-sectoral, interconnected, and complex.…”