Women coaches at top level: Looking back through the maze

Abstract

Framed in the Ecological-Intersectional Model and the Stages of Career Progression Model, the objective of this study was to explore how women coaching in high-performance settings advanced through the ‘bottle-neck’ path. In total 13 women coaches from Southern Europe between the age of 28 and 46 years working in high-performance contexts were interviewed. In order to assess both the subjective perceptions of participants and the structural factors that prevent women from accessing top-level positions, we adopted a critical realist perspective to perform a thematic analysis. Results show that while women coaches may follow a linear coaching career path in their early career stages, once they try to progress to high-performance settings their careers are shaped by the metaphor of a maze. Women need to navigate through a maze while having to overcome jeopardizing factors to find a succeeding career path in sports coaching. Moreover, previous experience as elite athletes, close entourage, role models, organizational support, precarious working conditions and motherhood influenced women's development of a coaching career, with differing relevance depending on the career stage. Women coaches who reach top-level positions associate their success with casual or external factors, instead of causal explanations related to their own achievements. We add evidence on the specificities of women's coaching careers that should be addressed not only to improve their recruitment and professional progression, but also to work on reducing the probabilities of women exiting the role.

Del césped al banquillo: trayectorias de futbolistas semiprofesionales en su transición de jugar a entrenar

“…Esto nos permite señalar la existente invisibilidad de la mujer en el fútbol y la importancia de crear alianzas de apoyo sobre cuestiones de género para permitir el desarrollo de las mujeres en este deporte. Estos resultados sobre la invisibilidad de la mujer apoyan lo que también ha sido marcado recientemente por Borrueco, Torregrossa, Pallarès et al, (2022) tras analizar las trayectorias de las mujeres entrenadoras de alto rendimiento.…”

The Impact of Motherhood on Women’s Career Progression: A Scoping Review of Evidence-Based Interventions

“…A lower sense of control over professional life was identified, followed by negative feelings like stress and guilt, lower satisfaction with their achievements, more fear of job loss, and a lower sense of entitlement to use benefits such as reduced hours or maternity leave [35,[39][40][41][42]. Additionally, mothers experienced a lower sense of belonging at work, as they often had to prove themselves by putting more effort in to achieve higher positions than their childfree counterparts [30].…”

Self-care as self-preservation: where is the support for coaches' self-care in Canadian sport?

“…Scholars exploring different facets of sport work, including sport coaching, have also examined the normalization of overwork (including, but not limited to, sport coaching as precarious labour) and its negative health consequences [e.g., see ( 23 – 26 )]. Sport coaching, as a profession in Canada, is unregulated, requiring coaches (volunteer or otherwise) to navigate the vast and messy domain of work that often necessitates going above and beyond traditional coaching roles.…”