Women’s perception of quality of maternity services: a longitudinal survey in Nepal

Abstract

BackgroundIn the context of maternity service, the mother’s assessment of quality is central because emotional, cultural and respectful supports are vital during labour and the delivery process. This study compared client-perceived quality of maternity services between birth centres, public and private hospitals in a central hills district of Nepal.MethodsA cohort of 701 pregnant women of 5 months or more gestational age were recruited and interviewed, followed by another interview within 45 days of delivery. Perception of quality was measured by a 20-item scale with three sub-scales: health facility, health care delivery, and interpersonal aspects. Perceived quality scores were analysed by ANOVA with post-hoc comparisons and multiple linear regression.ResultsWithin the health facility sub-scale, birth centre was rated lowest on items ‘adequacy of medical equipment’, ‘health staff suited to women’s health’ and ‘adequacy of health staff’, whereas public hospital was rated the lowest with respect to ‘adequacy of room’, ‘adequacy of water’, ‘environment clean’, ‘privacy’ and ‘adequacy of information’. Mean scores of total quality and sub-scales health facility and health care delivery for women attending private hospital were higher (p < 0.001) than those using birth centre or public hospital. Mean score of the sub-scale interpersonal aspects for public hospital users was lower (p < 0.001) than those delivered at private hospital and birth centre. However, perception on interpersonal aspects by women using public hospital improved significantly after delivery (p < 0.001).ConclusionsOverall, perception of quality differed significantly by types of health facility used for delivery. They rated lowest the supplies and equipment in birth centres and the amenities and interpersonal aspects in the public hospital. Accordingly, attention to these aspects is needed to improve the quality.

Limited Service Availability, Readiness, and Use of Facility-Based Delivery Care in Haiti: A Study Linking Health Facility Data and Population Data

“…Physical access as an important barrier to service use in rural Haiti was also demonstrated in previous research that measured access with the distance to the nearest facility reported by key community informants 23 . Our finding also agrees with previous research that having physical access to services is a strong determinant of use of delivery care 28 , 34 – 36 …”

Using photovoice to examine community level barriers affecting maternal health in rural Wakiso district, Uganda

“…This community thought quality of health care was better in private facilities compared to government ones, which is also reported elsewhere, 34,35 and reduces utilisation of services as well. 36 Indeed, it is well known that the poor attitudes of health workers towards patients, including pregnant women, is a major contributory factor in shunning of facilities.…”

Bypassing Primary Care Facilities for Childbirth: Findings from a Multilevel Analysis of Skilled Birth Attendance Determinants in Afghanistan

“…The pervasiveness of disrespect and abuse in facility‐based birth care has recently been highlighted as a barrier to care in many settings, and there is evidence suggesting this may be a more powerful deterrent to skilled birth attendance than other more commonly recognized barriers such as distance and cost . Multiple factors may contribute to unfriendliness of staff or lack of respectful care, including under‐equipped health facilities, overwhelmed or underpaid health care workers, lack of guidance and supportive supervisions, and an attitude of disrespect for patients that permeates the health system …”