Working Online During COVID-19: Accounts of First Year Students Experiences and Well-Being

Abstract

The sudden move to online learning due to the COVID-19 pandemic has created an influx of epistemological, psycho-social, emotional and financial challenges for first year students. Lecturers and academics had to find creative and sustainable ways of ensuring that all students were epistemologically included. New policies and practices were introduced rapidly at universities to facilitate the unavoidable move to online learning. As initial teacher educators at a public University in South Africa we noted that the sudden move to working online has presented various challenges to first year students’ overall well-being which has further exacerbated issues of exclusion and marginalization for many. We argue that it is against this backdrop that this paper explores how the move to online learning has affected first year students’ overall well-being, at one teacher education institution. The Index for Inclusive Education was used as a theoretical lens to explore student’s perceptions of the institution’s policy, teaching and learning practices, and the institutional culture during this period. One hundred and eighty-seven purposively selected first year students participated in this qualitative, phenomenological research study. Data were collected by means of open-ended questionnaires. Responses were categorized by means of an emergent thematic analysis. The findings indicated that online learning compromised various aspects of well-being including physical, emotional, psycho-social and financial well-being for many students. The experiences of online learning and impact on well-being did, however, differ across students depending on their individual contexts and circumstances indicating that considerations of well-being need to take contextual realities into account to support the well-being and learning of all. We recommend that higher education institutions prioritize the psycho-social, emotional, and financial well-being of students during the period of online learning and not just the pedagogic needs of the qualification.

Changing learning paradigms: an interplay of Digital Taylorism and technostress on perceived employability

“…Now, as higher education zips towards automation under what may be described as the new “technocratic imperative”, we see the emergence of online learning platforms to further improve the efficiency of instruction (Cavus and Zabadi, 2014). Online learning, or e-learning offers the benefit of targeted course offerings, location flexibility, time flexibility, immediate feedback and personalised learning to name a few (Moosa and Bekker, 2022). MOOCs, a flagship of e-learning, and have become an important ingredient of discourse in tertiary education (Liapis et al , 2022; Oh et al , 2020).…”

An analysis of digital stories of self-care practices among first- year students at a university of technology in South Africa

“…As a consequence of COVID-19, first-year students have had to navigate major life transitions together with the unanticipated move to online teaching and learning (Combrink & Oosthuizen, 2020), which all occurred in the new and unfamiliar university environment (Nyar, 2021). Not surprisingly, Moosa and Bekker (2022) found that first-year students in South Africa experienced anxiety due to the pandemic and its ramifications.…”

“…For example, Bantjes et al (2022) found higher rates of non-fatal suicidal behaviour among first-year university students in South Africa. Stressors related to the first-year experience in the context of COVID-19 compromised the various aspects of South African first-year students' well-being including the physical, emotional, social and financial (Moosa & Bekker, 2022). Getting enough sleep, healthy eating, and exercising have been reported in assisting students with experiencing less stress and negative mental health challenges (Moses et al, 2016).…”