Workplace bullying among nurses working in tertiary hospitals in Enugu, southeast Nigeria: Implications for health workers and job performance

Abstract

Background: Workplace bullying among nurses has been identified as a major contributor to poor attitude towards duties, and reduction in overall productivity. This study examined the occurrence and effects of behaviors that constitute workplace bullying among nurses in tertiary hospitals in Enugu, Southeast Nigeria. Methods: Data were collected from 286 nurses working in 4 tertiary hospitals in Enugu State, Southeast, Nigeria, using a modified 22-item Negative Acts Questionnaire (NAQ) for measuring bullying behaviors in the workplace, and a 26-item General Health Questionnaire (GHQ) for measuring the impact of bullying. Results: The prevalence of workplace bullying among nurses working in tertiary hospitals in Enugu is reported to be high. Data provided by the respondents in relation to prevalence was greatly affected by poor knowledge of what constitutes workplace bullying among nurses. A total of 82.6% of the respondents reported that they have been victims of workplace bullying. Behaviors observed most (on daily basis) over the 6-month period preceding the study include gossiping (22.0%), backbiting (18.7%), excessive workload without supervision (17.3%), failure to respect privacy (13.1%), intimidation (12.6%), humiliating someone in front of others including patients (12.1%) and unfair allocation of job and postings (8.4%). The main perpetrators of workplace bullying were identified by 76% of the respondents as senior nurses overseeing hospital wards/units, 84.1% of the respondents also indicated that nurses in junior cadre were the main targets. Female nurses were identified as the main perpetrators and targets of workplace bullying among nurses by 93.9% and 92.1% of the respondents respectively. The reported impact of workplace bullying among nurses include anger (50.5%), an intention to travel abroad because of the feeling that the prevalence is less there (33.6%), anxiety (21.5%), frustration (16.8%) and strained social relationships amongst colleagues (11.2%). Conclusions: Workplace bullying (mainly from senior nurses to junior ones) is highly prevalent and has significant impact on the health, job performance and retention rate of nurses working in tertiary hospitals in Enugu. Poor knowledge of what constitutes workplace bullying among nurses, relational aggression and female oppression have great implication in the prevalence, nature of bullying behaviors exhibited, characteristics of the perpetrators and the outcome of workplace bullying among the nurses. In order to reduce the prevalence of workplace bullying among nurses working in tertiary hospitals in Enugu, the nurses do not only require education on what constitutes workplace bullying, they also need adequate information about how to communicate respectfully with each other in the workplace. Nurse leaders and hospital administrators should also constitute disciplinary committees, encourage nurses to report the incidence of workplace bullying, punish perpetrators as well as protect those who report the cases from further attacks of bullying thro...

Workplace Bullying and its effect on Staff Nurses' Work Engagement

“…The result of present study was agreed with Fountain (2016) (15) who revealed that staff nurses, those nurses who work on medical/surgical units and those who work in non-acute hospital settings had lower levels of work engagement. Conversely, the result of present study was disagreed with, Badran (2019) (37) who revealed that less than two-thirds of the sample had moderate work engagement level.…”

Bullying in the nursing work environment: integrative review

“…It should be noted that most of the studies were published in Asia (39.5%), followed by North America (31.5%). Few publications on the subject were found for South America and Africa, indicating the need for further studies in these localities (16,28) .…”

“…Most articles sought to identify the existence of bullying among nursing professionals using specific data collection instruments in the fields of psychology and health care. In this review, we observed a predominance of the Negative Acts Questionnaire Revised (NAQ-R), used in 21 studies (2,10,11,14,(22)(23)(24)(25)(26)28,(33)(34)(35)(36)(37)39,41,44,(46)(47)(48)(49)52) . The original version of this instrument contains 22 items that report negative acts in the work environment and it is widely used in research on bullying (53) .…”

“…With regard to nursing, studies show that the effects of this type of violence on workers go beyond the physical and emotional manifestations, often demonstrated by high levels of stress, anxiety and depression (29) . Professional development is also affected by bullying, which can be perceived by an increase in absenteeism that reduces productivity and efficiency and causes social isolation, dissatisfaction with work and coworkers, often resulting in job abandonment (21)(22)24,28,38,52) .…”

Narratives of Working Mothers Experiencing Workplace Bullying: Trauma Transferred to Young Children

“…), which often resulted in depression and psychological burnout. In terms of workplace bullying, relational aggression, where a perpetrator uses a relationship to inflict social harm on a victim, is more common among female than male employees (Nwaneri, Onoka, & Onoka, 2016), perhaps because women's sensitivity to their psychosocial surroundings enables them to better identify relational aggression than men (Denton, Prus, & Walter, 2004;Seo, 2010). Also, women experience interpersonal distress relatively easily due to the high value they place on interpersonal relationships (Raskauskas & Stoltz, 2004;Rose, Swenson, Lance, Rose, & Randolph, 2006).…”