Myasthenia gravis is a neuroimmunological disorder leading to skeletal muscle weakness. Common symptoms of the disease, such as anxiety, depression, and insomnia, can cause significant distress in patients. Unfortunately, selecting an appropriate medication for treatment of psychiatric comorbidities can prove to be challenging for providers given the unique pharmacologic constraints that myasthenia gravis presents. The authors present the following clinical vignette and accompanying discussion in an attempt to highlight the special considerations that must be taken into account when treating anxiety and insomnia in patients with myasthenia gravis, as well as to provide an overview of available medication options through the lens of existing constraints.