Written Reflection Influences Science Students’ Perceptions of Their Own and Their Peers’ Teamwork and Related Employability Skills

Abstract

The impact of written reflection on tertiary students’ self-efficacy, and corresponding evaluation of their peers’ abilities, is often imprecise and lacking in clarity. This study thus sought to assess the effects of a written reflective diary on science undergraduates’ teamwork-related and other employability skills. Employability skills, in particular students’ teamwork-related skills, are crucial to students’ career development and progression. Assessment was carried out using a series of pre- and post-reflection online surveys, the TeamQ assessment rubric, and student focus groups. Participants identified five key teamwork skills, the importance of which remained constant over time. Written reflection had a significant, positive effect on students’ self-efficacy of their oral communication skills. Students’ written reflections were also important in shaping their perceptions about the domain of fostering a team climate, both in terms of their own self-efficacy and perceptions of their peers’ abilities. This study has interesting implications for future research into science students’ teamwork and other employability skills.

Quality of Feedback and Its Influence on the Preparation of the Future Teacher

“…Your own self-reflection can also have a significant impact. Hiscox, Papakonstantinou and Rayner (2022) conducted research and report that written reflection had a significant positive impact on students' self-efficacy in their oral presentation and communication skills.…”

How transformational leadership promotes employee creativity within the context of environmental dynamism: a multilevel perspective

“…This study constructs a parallel mediated pathway model of transformational leadership to creativity. In contrast to previous studies by Zuraik and Kelly (2019), Fu et al (2022), Hiscox et al (2022) that examined these variables separately, our study investigates their interconnections and cumulative effects. Furthermore, this study considers environmental dynamism as a moderating variable and examines its role in shaping the relationship between transformational leadership and creativity.…”

“…In contrast to previous studies by Zuraik and Kelly (2019), Fu et al . (2022), Hiscox et al . (2022) that examined these variables separately, our study investigates their interconnections and cumulative effects.…”

Critical thinking development in physics courses by PBL in virtual collaboration environments

“…Simultaneously, collaboration and negotiation between peers is made difficult due to the lack of soft skills necessary for collaborative work. Specifically, at the Escuela Superior de Cómputo (ESCOM) of the Instituto Politécnico Nacional (IPN), a survey was carried out on the experience of working in class (Hiscox, Papakonstantinou, & Rayner, 2022). The results showed a preference for individual work since most classes require students to work alone with a computer and almost no interaction with others.…”