The efficiency and fidelity of nucleotide incorporation by high-fidelity replicative DNA polymerases (Pols) are governed by the geometric constraints imposed upon the nascent base pair by the active site. Consequently, these polymerases can efficiently and accurately replicate through the template bases which are isosteric to natural DNA bases but which lack the ability to engage in Watson-Crick (W-C) hydrogen bonding. DNA synthesis by Pol, a low-fidelity polymerase able to replicate through DNA lesions, however, is inhibited in the presence of such an analog, suggesting a dependence of this polymerase upon W-C hydrogen bonding. Here we examine whether human Pol, which differs from Pol in having a higher fidelity and which, unlike Pol, is inhibited at inserting nucleotides opposite DNA lesions, shows less of a dependence upon W-C hydrogen bonding than does Pol. We find that an isosteric thymidine analog is replicated with low efficiency by Pol, whereas a nucleobase analog lacking minor-groove H bonding potential is replicated with high efficiency. These observations suggest that both Pol and Pol rely on W-C hydrogen bonding for localizing the nascent base pair in the active site for the polymerization reaction to occur, thus overcoming these enzymes' low geometric selectivity.Classical DNA polymerases (Pols) replicate DNA with a high fidelity and are unable to replicate through DNA-distorting lesions. From studies with nonpolar, isosteric analogs, which lack the ability to form canonical Watson-Crick (W-C) hydrogen bonds, it has been concluded that W-C H bonding is not the determining factor for the efficiency and accuracy of nucleotide incorporation in high-fidelity polymerases such as T7 and Escherichia coli Pol I (20, 23, 24); rather, it is apparently the geometric fit within the active site of the incoming nucleoside triphosphate with the templating nucleotide that governs polymerase efficiency and accuracy (3,5,13,15).Members of the Y family of DNA polymerases replicate DNA with a low fidelity, and unlike the classical polymerases, they are able to replicate through DNA lesions (28, 29). Humans have four Y family Pols: , , , and Rev1. Of these, Rev1 is a highly specialized polymerase which predominantly incorporates a C opposite template G and also opposite an abasic site (8,26), and genetic studies of Saccharomyces cerevisiae have suggested that a major role of Rev1 is to act as an assembly factor in Pol-dependent lesion bypass (28). Although not as extreme in its nucleotide insertion specificity as Rev1, Pol incorporates nucleotides opposite the four different template bases with very different efficiencies and fidelities, and it incorporates nucleotides opposite template purines with a much higher efficiency and fidelity than opposite template pyrimidines (6,11,34,39,46). From the ternary crystal structure of Pol, with a templating A and an incoming dTTP, it has been determined that unlike all other DNA polymerases, which impose Watson-Crick base pairing in their active site, Pol uses Hoogsteen base pair...