Young Women’s Mental Illness and (In-)visible Social Media Practices of Control and Emotional Recognition

Abstract

What “counts” as a mental illness–related image matters. Most research attention has focused on distressing or recognizable mental illness–related visual practices, yet this offers partial insight into youth mental health. Using visibility and practice theories, I share an in-depth case study exploring the social media practices of four young women, aged 14–17 years, engaged with an Australian adolescent psychiatric service. They describe how being visible to others on social media potentially produces anxiety and burdens them to respond to others’ questions or unhelpful support. In response, they engage in practices of control to manage the vulnerability of mental illness and burdensome sociality. Their mental illness–related media practices are often invisible; they rework mental illness through ambiguous, supportive or humorous practices or, through imagined intimacy, engage with images that feel relatable to them even if the images do not depict recognizable mental illness content or employ recognizable hashtags or titles. These insights complicate “what counts” as mental illness–related content or practices on social media and challenge researchers and practitioners to consider the sociotechnical contexts that shape young people’s mental health.

Constructing Authenticity on TikTok: Social Norms and Social Support on the "Fun" Platform

“…That is, humor may "mitigate the gravity of negative emotions" [86] and make negative expressions both less likely to be sanctioned and more palatable to other users. Humorous content, such as memes, may also provide a means of expression on stigmatized topics, such as mental health [7], [36]. Through similar mechanisms, humor may undercut a pressure to present a curated self and allow a more socially acceptable way of authentically declaring "look I'm a real person, my life is a mess too" [19].…”

‘#OkBoomer, time to meet the Zoomers’: studying the memefication of intergenerational politics on TikTok

“…Early adolescence is a period of vulnerability for the development of mental health issues (McLaughlin & King, 2015). Although the use and presence of social media can be a source of mental health strain for young people (Hendry, 2020), it can also be used to express their struggles with mental well-being. In our data, many adolescentappearing TikTokers convey feelings of insufficient support from their parents or feelings of complete neglect.…”

Doing Bodies in YouTube Videos about Contested Illnesses

“…They offer a more nuanced understanding of the multiple ways in which blogging might be of personal value to its protagonists. While many of these studies take online data as their source for analysis, Nathalie Ann Hendry's (2020) study on the mental health-related online practices of adolescents offers a noteworthy alternative. Using a productive combination of ethnographic research methods (i.e.…”