Building on a proof
of concept study that showed the possibility of the mechanochemical
insertion of some M(II) metals into meso-tetraphenylporphyrin
using a ball mill as an alternative to traditional solution-based
methods, we present here a detailed study of the influence of the
many experimental variables on the reaction outcome performed in a
planetary mill. Using primarily the mechanochemical zinc, copper,
and magnesium insertion reactions, the scope and limits of the type
of porphyrins (electron-rich or electron-poor meso-tetraarylporphyrins, synthetic or naturally occurring octaalkylporphyrins,
and meso-triphenylcorrole) and metal ion sources
suitable for this metal insertion modality were determined. We demonstrate
the influence of the experimental metal insertion parameters, such
as ball mill speed and reaction time, and investigated the often surprising
roles of a variety of grinding agents. Also, the mechanochemical reaction
conditions that remove zinc from a zinc porphyrin complex or exchange
it for copper were studied. Using some standardized conditions, we
also screened the feasibility of a number of other metal(II) insertion
reactions (VO, Ni, Fe, Co, Ag, Cd, Pd, Pt, Pb). The underlying factors
determining the rates of the insertion reactions were found to be
complex and not always readily predictable. Some findings of fundamental
significance for the mechanistic understanding of the mechanochemical
insertion of metal ions into porphyrins are highlighted. Particularly
the mechanochemical insertion of Mg(II) is a mild alternative to established
solution methods. The work provides a baseline from which the practitioner
may start to evaluate the mechanochemical metal insertion into porphyrins
using a planetary ball mill.