Self-association of four benzoic acid derivatives 2chloro-4-nitrobenzoic acid, 2-methyl-4-nitrobenzoic acid, 3hydroxybenzoic acid, and 2,6-dimethoxybenzoic acid in solution was investigated using spectroscopic measurements (Fourier transform infrared and 1 H and 13 C NMR spectroscopy) and molecular simulation methods. Based on the formation of hydrogen bonds, solvents can be divided into two groups: apolar solvents or solvents with a low hydrogen bond acceptor propensity, in which the benzoic acid derivatives form hydrogen-bonded dimers, and solvents with hydrogen bond acceptor propensity β > 0.3, interacting with the carboxylic group of benzoic acid, thus screening its interaction in the formation of self-associates. The formation propensity and structure of self-associates stabilized by weak interactions, such as π•••π stacking and CH 3 •••π interactions, however, are determined by the substituents in the benzene ring. Despite all the studied compounds being polymorphic, in none of the cases, an unequivocal structural link between self-associates present in the solution and the crystal form was observed.

2,6-Dimethoxyphenylboronic acid was used as a model substance to investigate the additive crystallization approach for polymorph control in phenylboronic acids. It was crystallized under different conditions by performing evaporation and cooling crystallization from different solvents. Most of the crystallizations from pure solvents produced the thermodynamically stable Form I, but in evaporation crystallization from alcohols, Form II or even a new polymorph, Form III, could be obtained. Structurally related substances, polymers, and surfactants with diverse intermolecular interaction possibilities were tested as additives. Surfactants were found to facilitate the crystallization of the metastable forms and therefore were investigated more extensively. The surfactants Span 20 and n–octyl-β-D-glucopyranoside provided crystallization of the metastable forms in the evaporation crystallization and notably stabilized Form II. The lattice energy, energy frameworks, Hirshfeld surface analysis, full interaction maps, and morphology prediction were used to identify the structural differences between Forms I and II and rationalize the ability of the additives to provide formation of Form II in the crystallization and to stabilize it.

In this study, 2,6-dimethoxybenzoic acid (2,6MeOBA) was used as a model substance to investigate the use of additives to control the polymorphic outcome of crystallization. 2,6MeOBA exists as three polymorphs. Two of the 2,6MeOBA polymorphs, I and III, obtained in most of the crystallization experiments, were characterized by thermal analysis, and their relative thermodynamic stability was determined. Forms I and III are enantiotropically related, where form III is the high-temperature form. Pure form II was very difficult to obtain. Crystallization of 2,6MeOBA was explored under different conditions by performing evaporation and cooling crystallization from different solvents. Surfactants, polymers, and different molecular compounds with diverse possibilities for the formation of intermolecular interactions were tested as additives. The additives facilitating the crystallization of the metastable forms were additionally studied under different crystallization conditions. The effect of additives polyethylene glycol (PEG) and hydroxypropyl cellulose (HPC) on the thermodynamic stability and solvent-mediated phase transition (SMPT) kinetics was evaluated. HPC and PEG showed the potential to favor the formation of form III in crystallization from water.

No abstract

The possibility to modify the morphology by crystallization additives of model substances was studied using molecular dynamics simulations. For this 2,6-dimethoxybenzoic acid and 3-hydroxybenzoic acid, each having two polymorphic forms, including a form without carboxylic acid homodimers in their crystal structure were selected. For each polymorph 2-3 largest crystal faces were selected for the study and the crystal was cut along these planes by preparing a simulation box with these planes facing towards solution containing additives. In the performed study it was evaluated which additives potentially can influence the crystal morphology and possibly also polymorph obtained in the crystallization by significantly changing the growth rate of crystal by adsorbing on the surface. For the study 4-5 additives providing different intermolecular interaction possibilities were selected. Among the studied additives urea showed the most complete adsorption and the longest residence time on surfaces of both substances, with the exceptions of few specific planes.