BackgroundThe evolution of reproductive self-sacrifice is well understood from kin theory, yet our understanding of how actual genes influence the expression of reproductive altruism is only beginning to take shape. As a model in the molecular study of social behaviour, the honey bee Apis mellifera has yielded hundreds of genes associated in their expression with differences in reproductive status of females, including genes directly associated with sterility, yet there has not been an attempt to link these candidates into functional networks that explain how workers regulate sterility in the presence of queen pheromone. In this study we use available microarray data and a co-citation analysis to describe what gene interactions might regulate a worker’s response to ovary suppressing queen pheromone.ResultsWe reconstructed a total of nine gene networks that vary in size and gene composition, but that are significantly enriched for genes of reproductive function. The networks identify, for the first time, which candidate microarray genes are of functional importance, as evidenced by their degree of connectivity to other genes within each of the inferred networks. Our study identifies single genes of interest related to oogenesis, including eggless, and further implicates pathways related to insulin, ecdysteroid, and dopamine signaling as potentially important to reproductive decision making in honey bees.ConclusionsThe networks derived here appear to be variable in gene composition, hub gene identity, and the overall interactions they describe. One interpretation is that workers use different networks to control personal reproduction via ovary activation, perhaps as a function of age or environmental circumstance. Alternatively, the multiple networks inferred here may represent segments of the larger, single network that remains unknown in its entirety. The networks generated here are provisional but do offer a new multi-gene framework for understanding how honey bees regulate personal reproduction within their highly social breeding system.

PIWI proteins are members of the larger Argonaute family and bind to specific 24-32 nucleotide RNAs called PIWI-interacting RNAs (piRNAs). PIWI-interacting RNAs direct PIWI-mediated suppression of retrotransposon expression in the male germline in humans and mice, but their roles in bovine reproduction and embryogenesis are unknown. Although the majority of research in mammals has focused on the functions of PIWI proteins during spermatogenesis, this family of proteins and their associated piRNAs have recently been identified in early embryos. The goals of this study were to characterize the expression of PIWIL1 in bovine testis, oocytes, and early embryos. A full-lengthPIWIL1transcript and protein was found in the testis, specifically in the germs cells of mature seminiferous tubules. RNA-immunoprecipitation demonstrated the presence of putative piRNAs with a mean length of 30 nucleotides bound to PIWIL1 in testes. 3'-Rapid amplification of cDNA ends analysis ofPIWIL1transcripts in testes and oocytes revealed two shorter isoforms in addition to the full-length transcript that was only present in testes. TruncatedPIWIL1isoforms in oocytes and testes were confirmed through amplification of their unique intronic fragments. Expression profiling ofPIWIL1through early embryogenesis demonstrated peak mRNA expression at the 2-cell stage with decreasing levels through to the blastocyst. PIWIL1-YFP fusion plasmids were produced for each isoform and expressed in HEK 293 cells, demonstrating nuclear exclusion and size-specific banding of the different isoforms. These data represent the first comprehensive characterization of PIWIL1 in bovine, revealing functional similarities with PIWIL1 in other species and suggest tissue-specific expression of several isoforms.

A conspicuous feature of honey bee social biology is the division of labour between reproductive queens and functionally sterile workers. However, the sterility of workers is conditional and sensitive to genetic and environmental context. Despite this understanding, we do not yet know how effective differences in genotype versus differences in colony environment are for generating variation in levels of ovary activation in a population of workers. We therefore performed a field study and meta-analysis to estimate the standardized effect size g of broad 'environmental' and 'genetic' manipulations on worker ovary scores. Despite considerable differences in methodology and treatment among published studies, we report that both genetic and environmental manipulations were effective at generating differences in ovary phenotype between groups of worker bees. Our analysis found that environmental treatments, such as differences in pheromones and diet, had a larger mean effect on worker ovary activation scores than have genetic factors such as patriline or strain (g = 0.54 vs. 0.39). We conclude by discussing the biological significance of environmentally sensitive sterility in honey bee societies.

The PIWI clade of Argonaute proteins is essential for spermatogenesis in all species examined to date. This protein family binds specific classes of small non-coding RNAs known as PIWI-interacting RNAs (piRNAs) which together form piRNA-induced silencing complexes (piRISCs) that are recruited to specific RNA targets through sequence complementarity. These complexes facilitate gene silencing through endonuclease activity and guided recruitment of epigenetic silencing factors. PIWI proteins and piRNAs have been found to play multiple roles in the testis including the maintenance of genomic integrity through transposon silencing and facilitating the turnover of coding RNAs during spermatogenesis. In the present study, we report the first characterization of PIWIL1 in the male domestic cat, a mammalian system predicted to express four PIWI family members. Multiple transcript variants of PIWIL1 were cloned from feline testes cDNA. One isoform shows high homology to PIWIL1 from other mammals, however, the other has characteristics of a “slicer null” isoform, lacking the domain required for endonuclease activity. Expression of PIWIL1 in the male cat appears limited to the testis and correlates with sexual maturity. RNA-immunoprecipitation revealed that feline PIWIL1 binds small RNAs with an average size of 29 nt. Together, these data suggest that the domestic cat has two PIWIL1 isoforms expressed in the mature testis, at least one of which interacts with piRNAs.