End-user Service Composition (EUSC) is defined as service composition where the person who creates the composite service also uses it. We derived requirements for EUSC tools using a custom method based on the scenario-based requirements analysis method. Ten participants were given scenarios, a demonstrator application and examples of EUSC tools before being interviewed. Analysing their responses, we elicited 139 requirements across topics including service ''types'' (e.g. pervasive services), composition flow (i.e. control/data flow) and the use of templates in composition. This is the first published work to have used a robust requirements analysis method in EUSC, adapted specifically to take account of prior work on EUSC. Some of our requirements validate those found in prior research or current EUSC tools but many are unique to our findings. The requirements found in this work inform and inspire the development of future EUSC tools, and the methodology is easily adapted for application in other domains.