In addition to controlling typical instabilities such as physical and chemical degradations, understanding monoclonal antibodies' (mAbs) solution behavior is a key step in designing and developing process and formulation controls during their development. Reversible self-association (RSA), a unique solution property in which native, reversible oligomeric species are formed as a result of the noncovalent intermolecular interactions has been recognized as a developability risk with the potential to negatively impact manufacturing, storage stability, and delivery of mAbs. Therefore, its identification, characterization, and mitigation are key requirements during formulation development. Considering the large number of available analytical methods, choice of the employed technique is an important contributing factor for successful investigation of RSA. Herein, a multitechnique (dynamic light scattering, multiangle static light scattering, and analytical ultracentrifugation) approach is employed to comprehensively characterize the self-association of a model immunoglobulin G1 molecule. Studies herein discuss an effective approach for detection and characterization of RSA during biopharmaceutical development based on the capabilities of each technique, their complementarity, and more importantly their suitability for the stage of development in which RSA is investigated.
Electrostatically driven attractions between proteins can result in issues for therapeutic protein formulations such as solubility limits, aggregation, and high solution viscosity. Previous work showed that a model monoclonal antibody displayed large and potentially problematic electrostatically driven attractions at typical pH (5−8) and ionic strength conditions (∼10−100 mM). Molecular simulations of a hybrid coarse-grained model (1bC/D, one bead per charged site and per domain) were used to predict potential point mutations to identify key charge changes (charge-to-neutral or charge-swap) that could greatly reduce the net attractive protein−protein self-interactions. A series of variants were tested experimentally with static and dynamic light scattering to quantify interactions and compared to model predictions at low and intermediate ionic strength. Differential scanning calorimetry and circular dichroism confirmed minimal impact on structural or thermal stability of the variants. The model provided quantitative/semiquantitative predictions of protein self-interactions compared to experimental results as well as showed which amino acid pairings or groups had the most impact.
Some monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) are reported to display concentration-dependent reversible self-association (RSA). There are multiple studies that investigate the effect of RSA on product characteristics such as viscosity, opalescence, phase separation and aggregation. This work investigates the effects of RSA on a bind-and-elute mode cation exchange chromatography (CEX) unit operation. We report a case study in which the RSA of an IgG2 (mAb X) resulted in significant peak splitting during salt gradient elution in CEX. Multiple factors including resin type, load challenge, residence time and gradient slope were evaluated and demonstrated little effect on the peak splitting of mAb X. It was determined that high NaCl concentrations in combination with high protein concentrations induced mAb X to form one RSA species that binds more strongly to the column, resulting in a large second elution peak. The finding of NaCl-induced RSA suggested that lower NaCl elution concentrations and different types of salts could mitigate RSA and thus eliminate peak splitting. Different salts were tested, showing that chaotropic salts such as CaCl2 reduced the second elution peak by inducing less RSA. The addition of a positively charged amino acid (such as 50mM histidine) into the CEX elution buffer resulted in elution at lower NaCl concentrations and also effectively reduced peak splitting. However, experiments that were intended to reduce salt concentration by increasing the elution buffer pH did not significantly mitigate peak splitting. This is because higher pH conditions also increase RSA. This work identifies salt-induced RSA as the cause of peak splitting of a mAb in CEX and also provides solutions to reduce the phenomenon.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.