Empirical based approaches play an important role in tunnel excavation and support system design. These approaches are considered to be very effective in optimising the process of tunnel excavation and particularly tunnel widening. Several reliable empirical approaches have been developed, however the selection or utilisation of an appropriate empirical method for designing the widening of a tunnel is still a challenging task. Therefore, in this work, the analysis of seven different empirical design approaches was carried out to determine the rock mass behaviour during tunnel widening in high in-situ stress state. These approaches include New Austrian Tunnelling Method, Rock Mass Rating, Rock Mass Quality, Rock Mass Index, Rock Structure Rating, Geological Strength Index and Basic Quality Index. On the basis of simulated statistical results obtained from the said empirical approaches, it was found that the application of Rock Mass Quality approach is highly effective in the tunnel widening since it can satisfactorily incorporate the equivalent dimensions and in-situ stress condition of widened tunnel. The method furnishes optimised reinforcement and support design. Additionally, this study also produces reliable data related to the initial excavation of tunnel which can be helpful in defining precise rock mass parameters during tunnel widening.

To accommodate traffic volume on roads due to ever-increasing population growth, the widening of highways and motorways is in high demand. Nevertheless, the widening of tunnels on these road networks is quite complex due to the presence of numerous rock types, in situ stress, and different widening modes. To overcome these complexities, eight different tunnel shapes were simulated under varying support conditions for asymmetric and symmetric widening. It was found that the tunnels with a round shape, such as horseshoe and semicircular with flatbed, are more effective for asymmetric widening, whereas the provision of a rounded invert in these shapes can reverse the widening option to symmetric. Furthermore, an insignificant effect of the difference in asymmetric and symmetric widening of regular tunnel shapes, such as box, rectangular, and semi-elliptical, was found. A full factorial design statistical analysis confirmed the decrease in tunnel deformation by using various tunnel support systems and showed a significant deformation difference according to monitoring locations at the tunnel periphery. The deformation difference in the case of both tunnel widening modes was also analyzed according to different design parameters. This study provides a comprehensive understanding of rock mass behavior when the widening of any underground opening is carried out.