Oil shale, a fine-grained sedimentary rock, contains a proportionally large amount of kerogen, which can be converted into oil by thermal degradation of the compacted rock. The primary byproduct of current oil shale oil extraction processes is semicoke. Its landfill deposition presents a possible threat to the environment and represents a waste of a potentially useable byproduct. In this work, we explore the heavy metal content of oil shale semicoke pyrolyzed at 500 and 1000 °C to better understand the risks posed by disposal of oil shale processing waste on the nearby environment, as well as impediments to potential byproduct conversion. The greatest potential obstruction to byproduct conversion and the greatest environmental risk posed by open air disposal of oil shale semicoke is likely due to relatively high arsenic concentrations; using X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy, we find arsenic concentrations in semicoke (pyrolyzed at 500 °C) ranging from 25 ppm for Chinese oil shale from the Huadian mine (class C) to 79 ppm for Green River, Colorado, 50 gallons per ton (GPT) of oil shale. Other heavy metal elements analyzed, including barium, copper, lead, manganese, and iron, are well below the United States Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) regional screening limits.