No abstract

BackgroundAdaptive radiation in Mediterranean plants is poorly understood. The white-flowered Cistus lineage consists of 12 species primarily distributed in Mediterranean habitats and is herein subject to analysis.Methodology/Principal FindingsWe conducted a “total evidence” analysis combining nuclear (ncpGS, ITS) and plastid (trnL-trnF, trnK-matK, trnS-trnG, rbcL) DNA sequences and using MP and BI to test the hypothesis of radiation as suggested by previous phylogenetic results. One of the five well-supported lineages of the Cistus-Halimium complex, the white-flowered Cistus lineage, comprises the higher number of species (12) and is monophyletic. Molecular dating estimates a Mid Pleistocene (1.04±0.25 Ma) diversification of the white-flowered lineage into two groups (C. clusii and C. salviifolius lineages), which display asymmetric characteristics: number of species (2 vs. 10), leaf morphologies (linear vs. linear to ovate), floral characteristics (small, three-sepalled vs. small to large, three- or five-sepalled flowers) and ecological attributes (low-land vs. low-land to mountain environments). A positive phenotype-environment correlation has been detected by historical reconstructions of morphological traits (leaf shape, leaf labdanum content and leaf pubescence). Ecological evidence indicates that modifications of leaf shape and size, coupled with differences in labdanum secretion and pubescence density, appear to be related to success of new species in different Mediterranean habitats.Conclusions/SignificanceThe observation that radiation in the Cistus salviifolius lineage has been accompanied by the emergence of divergent leaf traits (such as shape, pubescence and labdanum secretion) in different environments suggets that radiation in the group has been adaptive. Here we argued that the diverse ecological conditions of Mediterranean habitats played a key role in directing the evolution of alternative leaf strategies in this plant group. Key innovation of morphological characteristics is supported by our dated phylogeny, in which a Mediterranean climate establishment (2.8 Ma) predated the adaptive radiation of the white-flowered Cistus.

Aim The post-glacial range dynamics of many European plant species have been widely investigated, but information rapidly diminishes as one moves further back in time. Here we infer the historical range shifts of Laurus, a paradigmatic tree of the Tethyan flora that has covered southern Eurasia since the Oligo-Miocene, by means of phylogenetic and phylogeographical analyses.Location Mediterranean Basin, Black Sea and Macaronesian archipelagos (Azores, Madeira, Canary Islands).Methods We analysed plastid DNA (cpDNA) sequence (trnK-matK, trnD-trnT) variation in 57 populations of Laurus and three Lauraceae genera. Phylogenetic methods (maximum parsimony and Bayesian inference) and statistical parsimony networks were used to reconstruct relationships among haplotypes. These results were contrasted with the fossil record and bioclimatic niche-based model predictions of past distributions to infer the migration routes and location of refugia. ResultsThe phylogenetic tree revealed monophyly for Laurus. Overall sequence variability was low within Laurus, but six different haplotypes were distinguished and a single network retrieved, portraying three lineages primarily related to geography. A strongly divergent eastern lineage occupied Turkey and the Near East, a second clade was located in the Aegean region and, lastly, a western clade grouped all Macaronesian and central and western Mediterranean populations. A close relationship was observed between the Macaronesian populations of L. azorica and the western populations of L. nobilis. Main conclusionsThe phylogeographical structure of Laurus preserves the imprints of an ancient contraction and break-up of the range that resulted in the evolution of separate cpDNA lineages in its western-and easternmost extremes. Intense range dynamics in the western Mediterranean and multiple glacial refugia contributed to the generation and long-term conservation of this phylogeographical pattern, as shown by the fit between the haplotype ranges and past suitable areas inferred from bioclimatic models. Finally, our results challenge the taxonomic separation of Laurus into two distinct species.

Aim There are few biogeographical and evolutionary studies that address plant colonization and lineage origins in the Mediterranean. Cistus serves as an excellent model with which to study diaspore dispersal and distribution patterns of plants exhibiting no special long-distance dispersal mechanisms. Here we analyse the pattern of genetic variation and divergence times to infer whether the African-European disjunction of C. ladanifer L. is the result of long-distance dispersal or of vicariance events.Location Principally the Western Mediterranean region, with a focus on the Strait of Gibraltar.Methods We used DNA sequence phylogenetic approaches, based on plastid (rbcL/trnK-matK) and nuclear (ITS) sequence data sets, and the penalized likelihood method, to date the diversification of the 21 species of Cistus. Phylogenetic relationships and phylogeographical patterns in 47 populations of C. ladanifer were also analysed using two plastid DNA regions (trnS-trnG, trnK-matK). These sequence data were analysed using maximum parsimony, Bayesian inference and statistical parsimony.Results Dating estimates indicated divergence dates of the C. ladanifer lineage in the Pleistocene. Eight nucleotide-substitution haplotypes distributed on the European (four haplotypes) and African (five haplotypes) sides of the Strait of Gibraltar were revealed from C. ladanifer sequences. Both the haplotype network and the phylogenetic analyses depicted two main Cistus lineages distributed in both Europe and North Africa. An Iberian haplotype forms part of the North African lineage, and another haplotype distributed on both continents is related to the European lineage. Haplotype relationships with respect to outgroup sequences supported the hypothesis that the centre of genetic diversity is in northern Africa.Main conclusions Based on lineage divergence-time estimates and disassociation between geographical and lineage haplotype distributions, we inferred at least two intercontinental colonization events of C. ladanifer postdating the opening of the Strait of Gibraltar (c. 5 Ma). This result supports a hypothesis of long-distance dispersal rather than a hypothesis of vicariance. We argue that, despite limited dispersal abilities, preference for disturbed habitats was integral to historical colonization after the advent of the Mediterranean climate (c. 3.2 Ma), when Cistus species diverged and became established as a dominant element in the Mediterranean scrub.

Aim  To infer phylogenetic relationships among Antirrhinum species and to reconstruct the historical distribution of observed sequence polymorphism through estimates of haplotype clades and lineage divergence. Location  Antirrhinum is distributed primarily throughout the western Mediterranean, with 22 of 25 species in the Iberian Peninsula. Methods  Plastid (83 trnS‐trnG and 83 trnK‐matK) and nuclear (87 ITS) sequences were obtained from 96 individuals representing 24 of the 25 Antirrhinum species. Sequences were analysed using maximum parsimony, Bayesian inference and statistical parsimony networking. Molecular clock estimates were obtained for plastid trnK‐matK sequences using the penalized likelihood approach. Results  Phylogenetic results gave limited support for monophyletic groups within Antirrhinum. Fifty‐one plastid haplotypes were detected and 27 missing haplotypes inferred, which were all connected in a single, star‐like network. A significant number of species shared both the same haplotypes and the same geographical areas, primarily in eastern Iberia. Furthermore, many species harboured populations with unrelated haplotypes from divergent haplotype clades. Plastid haplotype distribution, together with nucleotide additivity in 59 of the 86 nuclear ribosomal ITS sequences, is interpreted as evidence of extensive hybridization. Lineage divergence estimates indicated that differentiation within Antirrhinum post‐dates the Miocene, when the Mediterranean climate was established. Main conclusions  Incongruence between plastid sequences, nuclear sequences and taxonomic delimitation is interpreted as strong evidence of limited cladogenetic processes in Antirrhinum. Rather, extensive nucleotide additivities in ITS sequences in conjunction with haplotype and haplotype‐clade distributions related to geographical areas support both recent and ancient hybridization. This geographical pattern of Antirrhinum speciation, particularly in eastern Iberia, is congruent with isolation–contact–isolation processes in the Pleistocene.