The o-succinylbenzoate synthase (OSBS) family is part of the functionally diverse enolase superfamily. Many proteins in one branch of the OSBS family catalyze both OSBS and N-succinylamino acid racemization in the same active site. In some promiscuous NSAR/OSBS enzymes, NSAR activity is biologically significant in addition to or instead of OSBS activity. Identifying important residues for each reaction could provide insight into how proteins evolve new functions. We have made a series of mutations in Amycolatopsis sp. T-1-60 NSAR/OSBS in an active site loop, referred to as the 20s loop. This loop affects substrate specificity in many members of the enolase superfamily but is poorly conserved within the OSBS family. Deletion of this loop decreased OSBS and NSAR catalytic efficiency by 4500-fold and 25,000-fold, respectively, showing that it is essential. Most point mutations had small effects, changing the efficiency of both NSAR and OSBS activities <10-fold compared to that of the wild type. An exception was F19A, which reduced kcat/KM(OSBS) 200-fold and kcat/KM(NSAR) 120-fold. Mutating the surface residue R20E, which can form a salt bridge to help close the 20s loop over the active site, had a more modest effect, decreasing kcat/KM of OSBS and NSAR reactions 32- and 8-fold, respectively. Several mutations increased KM of the NSAR reaction more than that of the OSBS reaction. Thus, both activities require the 20s loop, but differences in how mutations affect OSBS and NSAR activities suggest that some substitutions in this loop made a small contribution to the evolution of NSAR activity, although additional mutations were probably required.

Promiscuity is the coincidental ability of an enzyme to catalyze its native reaction and additional reactions that are not biological functions in the same active site. Promiscuity plays a central role in enzyme evolution and is thus a useful property for protein and metabolic engineering. This review examines enzyme evolution holistically, beginning with evaluating biochemical support for four enzyme evolution models. As expected, there is strong biochemical support for the subfunctionalization and innovation–amplification–divergence models, in which promiscuity is a central feature. In many cases, however, enzyme evolution is more complex than the models indicate, suggesting much is yet to be learned about selective pressures on enzyme function. A complete understanding of enzyme evolution must also explain the ability of metabolic networks to integrate new enzyme activities. Hidden within metabolic networks are underground metabolic pathways constructed from promiscuous activities. We discuss efforts to determine the diversity and pervasiveness of underground metabolism. Remarkably, several studies have discovered that some metabolic defects can be repaired via multiple underground routes. In prokaryotes, metabolic innovation is driven by connecting enzymes acquired by horizontal gene transfer (HGT) into the metabolic network. Thus, we end the review by discussing how the combination of promiscuity and HGT contribute to evolution of metabolism in prokaryotes. Future studies investigating the contribution of promiscuity to enzyme and metabolic evolution will need to integrate deeper probes into the influence of evolution on protein biophysics, enzymology, and metabolism with more complex and realistic evolutionary models. Enzymes lactate dehydrogenase (EC 1.1.1.27), malate dehydrogenase (EC 1.1.1.37), OSBS (EC 4.2.1.113), HisA (EC 5.3.1.16), TrpF, PriA (EC 5.3.1.24), R‐mandelonitrile lyase (EC 4.1.2.10), Maleylacetate reductase (EC 1.3.1.32).