A pilot study was performed to evaluate the potential of an inert self-supported immersed fixed film media to upgrade aerated lagoons. Simultaneous organic matter removal and nitrification was assessed under different loading rates and temperatures (near 0 °C) using 12 laboratory-scale reactors operated in parallel. Test results showed that both the temperature and the load have an influence on organic matter effluent concentrations. Effluent quality seemed related to the observed biofilm thickness. Thicker biofilm is believed to have contributed to biomass detachment and increased particulate organic matter concentrations in the effluent. Simultaneous organic removal and nitrification was obtained at loads above 5 g CBOD/m·d. The highest nitrification rate at 0.4 °C was obtained for the smallest load, which showed a nitrification limitation close to freezing point.

A full-scale biofilm-enhanced aerated lagoon using fixed submerged media was monitored using automated water quality monitoring stations over the span of one year to quantify its nitrification performance. The system was operating at a high organic loading rate averaging 5.8 g total CBOD 5 /m 2 of media per day (23.9 g total CBOD 5 /m 3 of lagoon per day), a total ammonia nitrogen loading rate averaging 0.9 g NH 4-N/m 2 day (3.7 g NH 4-N/m 3 day), and temperatures ranging from 1.6 to 20.8°C. The system showed an extended seasonal nitrification period compared with a simulated aerated lagoon system of the same dimensions. This extension of complete nitrification with approximately 1 month was observed in the fall despite the decrease of operating temperature down to 4°C. During this maximum nitrification period, substantial denitrification occurred, and the effluent un-ionized ammonia ratio was reduced. A temporary loss of nitrification was also experienced in relation to an episode of elevated suspended solids concentration. Measured biofilm characteristics, namely the detachment dynamics and the biofilm thickness, were used to explain this temporary nitrification loss. During wintertime, a low nitrate production was still observed, suggesting yearlong retention of nitrifying bacteria in the biofilm.

An experimental study dedicated to the characterization of the settleability of solids produced in immersed fixed media biofilm reactors has been carried out. The influence of operating temperature (0.1 to 16 °C) and surface organic loading rate (OLR) (0.4 to 10 g of soluble carbonaceous BOD per m of media per day) on settleable solids quantities, particle size distributions (PSD) as well as flocs morphology was evaluated. Results have shown that the OLR has no statistically significant influence on the settleability of the suspended solids. However, the operating temperature was identified as a factor that significantly influences the settling potential. The highest operating temperatures (14-16 °C) were related to the worst settling performances. On the other hand, the best settling performances were observed at intermediate operating temperatures (around 10 °C). The latter conditions were also associated with the largest fractions of large particles (>100 μm) in the effluent. Differences in PSD were found to be well correlated with settling performances. Part of the performance results variability which cannot be explained by differences in PSD can potentially be attributed to differences in flocs morphology (compactness).