Background The immune checkpoint receptor programmed cell death protein I (PD-1) has been identified as a key target in immunotherapy. PD-1 reduces the risk of autoimmunity by inducing apoptosis in antigen-specific T cells upon interaction with programmed cell death protein ligand I (PD-L1). Various cancer types overexpress PD-L1 to evade the immune system by inducing apoptosis in tumor-specific CD8+ T cells. The clinically used blocking antibody nivolumab binds to PD-1 and inhibits the immunosuppressive interaction with PD-L1. Even though PD-1 is already used as a drug target, the exact mechanism of the receptor is still a matter of debate. For instance, it is hypothesized that the signal transduction is based on an active conformation of PD-1. Results Here we present the results of the first molecular dynamics simulations of PD-1 with a complete extracellular domain with a focus on the role of the BC-loop of PD-1 upon binding PD-L1 or nivolumab. We could demonstrate that the BC-loop can form three conformations. Nivolumab binds to the BC-loop according to the conformational selection model whereas PD-L1 induces allosterically a conformational change of the BC-loop. Conclusion Due to the structural differences of the BC-loop, a signal transduction based on active conformation cannot be ruled out. These findings will have an impact on drug design and will help to refine immunotherapy blocking antibodies.

To improve cancer immunotherapy, a clearer understanding of key targets such as the immune checkpoint receptor PD-1 is essential. The PD-1 inhibitors nivolumab and pembrolizumab were recently approved by the FDA. The CC′-loop of PD-1 has been identified as a hotspot for drug targeting. Here, we investigate the influence of nivolumab and pembrolizumab on the molecular motion of the CC′-loop of PD-1. We performed molecular dynamics simulations on the complete extracellular domain of PD-1, in complex with PD-L1, and the blocking antibodies nivolumab and pembrolizumab. Conformations of the CC′-loop were analyzed unsupervised with the Daura et al. clustering algorithm and multidimensional scaling. Surprisingly, two conformations found were seen to correspond to the ‘open’ and ‘closed’ conformation of CC′-loop in apo-PD-1, already known from literature. Unsupervised clustering also surprisingly reproduced the natural ligand, PD-L1, exclusively stabilizing the ‘closed’ conformation, as also known from literature. Nivolumab, like PD-L1, was found to shift the equilibrium towards the ‘closed’ conformation, in accordance with the conformational selection model. Pembrolizumab, on the other hand, induced a third conformation of the CC′-loop which has not been described to date: Relative to the conformation ‘open’ the, CC′-loop turned 180° to form a new conformation which we called ‘overturned’. We show that the combination of clustering and multidimensional scaling is a fast, easy, and powerful method in analyzing structural changes in proteins. Possible refined antibodies or new small molecular compounds could utilize the flexibility of the CC′-loop to improve immunotherapy.

No abstract