Small multidrug resistance (SMR) transporters efflux toxic substrates from bacterial cells. These transporters were recently divided into two subfamilies: the GdX-like and EmrE-like SMRs. The EmrE-like subfamily of SMRs is predicted to contain transporters that are highly promiscuous in both substrate specificity and mechanism based on extensive characterization of the founding member of this subfamily, EmrE. However, there is only limited functional analysis of other members of this family from pathogenic strains such as Staphylococcus aureus and Francisella tularensis. Here, we use a small compound screen to explore the substrate specificity and diversity of EmrE-subfamily SMRs from these two bacterial species and confirm that they are functionally more like EmrE than the GdX-like subfamily of toxic-metabolite transporters. The results of these experiments lay the foundation for understanding the complex substrate specificity profiles of SMR family transporters and assess the potential for targeting these transporters for future antibiotic development, either broadly or in a species-specific manner.