This article reports on a consecutive series of 3627 breast cancer (BC) patients undergoing preoperative staging by chest x-ray (CXR), bone x-ray (BXR) or bone scintigraphy (BS), and liver ecography (LE) or liver scintigraphy (LS). The detection rate (DR) of preclinical asymptomatic distant metastases depended on the T and N category (TNM classification system), and was very low (CXR: 0.30%, BXR: 0.64%, BS: 0.90%, LE: 0.24%, LS: 0.23%). The sensitivity, determined after a 6-month follow-up, was below 0.50% for all tests. The highest value (0.48%) was recorded for BS, which also had the lowest specificity (0.95%). The entire preoperative staging policy using the studied tests seems questionable due to poor sensitivity and an extremely low DR of distant metastases.
A multicenter series of 350 intraductal breast cancers (DCIS) is reported. Mammography was the most sensitive test but suspicion arose only at palpation in 13% of cases whereas in 10% of cases biopsy was recommended for a benign lesion and DCIS was an unexpected finding. Mammography, physical examination and cytology must be combined to achieve optimal sensitivity. Systematic biopsy of apparently benign masses would increase DCIS detection rates but the cost-effectiveness of such a policy is questionable. A trend of conservative surgery was evident over time (from 1968-79, 28%; 1985-1989, 50%) but breast irradiation followed only in one fourth of the cases. The local recurrence rate was significantly higher in cases of limited surgery (with or without irradiation) with respect to mastectomy (1.2 vs 0.2 x 100 patient-years at risk). Most recurrences (7 of 8) in the conserved breast were infiltrating, but no recurrence was seen in subclinical DCIS cases. Three patients died of breast cancer after local recurrence in the conserved breast (2 cases) or mastectomy scar (1 case). Eligibility for conservative surgery of DCIS needs to be carefully discussed to avoid under-treatment. Contralateral breast cancer was recorded in 44 cases and the incidence of further metachronous cancer to the other breast was ten times higher than expected in normal breasts. Four patients died of contralateral breast cancer, free of ipsilateral recurrence. A careful follow-up of the contralateral breast in DCIS cases looks as important as surveillance of the conserved breast.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.