There is considerable research exploring the criminalization of homelessness in Canadian cities, yet scant research attention has been devoted to exploring homeless youths' experiences with police. This study prioritizes the experiences of homeless youth themselves, to examine how they make sense of and respond to policing in Ottawa. Using a phenomenological design, the study's analysis is informed by focus groups and walking interviews conducted with homeless youth between 16 and 25 who utilize services at a drop-in-center in Ottawa. The analysis revealed two findings. First, young people felt paradoxically over-controlled and under-served in their encounters with police because of their intersecting identities as young and homeless in the city. Second, when responding to their encounters young people resisted and accepted the disciplinary and regulatory practices attached to policing in the city. To make sense of their responses I draw upon the concepts of reflexive subjectivity, affect and symbolic violence. This study adds knowledge to how young people make sense of and respond to policing in their everyday lives.