An experimental study was performed with an aged Co/Pt/Al 2 O 3 catalyst in a laboratory slurry reactor to develop a macrokinetic expression for the Fischer-Tropsch (FT) synthesis. A semiempirical model was found to be the preferred two-parameter rate equation of the reaction. However, it was shown that this model is virtually indistinguishable from a mechanistically derived three-parameter rate model that assumes the following kinetically relevant steps in the cobalt-FT synthesis: CO dissociation occurs without hydrogen interaction and is not a rate-limiting step; the first hydrogen addition to surface carbon and the second hydrogen addition to surface oxygen are the rate-determining steps.
Previously, the attainable region has been constructed for systems where the rate vector is uniquely defined. In this paper we extend the attainable region approach to situations where the rate vector depends on a control parameter, such as temperature. In these cases, the rate vector can take on a range of values, depending on the value of the control parameter. Arguments based on the geometry of the boundary of the attainable region are used to derive equations that describe the optimal control policies. These conditions are applied to various examples and both the optimal reactor structures as well as optimal operating and control policies are derived by looking at the structures that make up the boundary of the attainable region. In particular, an example is given where the optimal reactor structure has a reactor with simultaneous side stream addition and temperature control.
Attainable region analysis has been used to solve a large number of previously unsolved
optimization problems. This paper examines its relationship to Pontryagin's maximum principle
and highlights the similarities and differences between the methods. It is shown that not all
problems that can be solved by attainable region analysis are readily formulated as maximum
principle problems. The fundamental process of mixing seems to be the main reason for this
difference and the consequences of this are highlighted. The class of problems that can be
formulated as maximum principle problems are then examined and the relationship between
the two methods highlighted. Here, the maximum principle gives rise to a set of results that
are very useful for finding an attainable region. In fact, from these results and the experience
gained by solving AR problems, postulates on the nature of the boundary of the attainable region
are proposed. Previous to this work the construction of the attainable region required a trial
and error approach and the region thus generated was tested using the necessary conditions.
These postulates should allow a more constructive approach to finding the attainable region
boundary.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.