Turtles can be unintentionally hooked during recreational and commercial fishing operations. While hook ingestion is not always fatal, ingested hooks can harm or kill turtles by damaging soft tissues or affecting digestion. Detecting ingested hooks and other metallic debris in the field is a challenge. As such, we tested the efficacy of a handheld metal detector in detecting ingested fish hooks and incidental metallic debris in freshwater turtles in Georgia, USA. We captured 426 individual freshwater turtles representing 4 species and radiographed 106 yellow-bellied sliders (Trachemys scripta scripta). Of 37 turtles that tested positive with a handheld metal detector, radiographs revealed 17 (46%) had ingested at least one hook, 15 (40%) had ingested an unidentifiable metal object or objects, and 5 (14%) showed no clear signs of hooks or other metallic objects. All 69 turtles that tested negative in the field and were radiographed showed no signs of metal ingestion. Accordingly, our proportion of false positives was 14% (5 of 37), false negatives (metal not detected in field but on follow-up radiograph) were 0%