There is an evident misprint in the labeling of the Raman features in the first sentence of the first paragraph in the first column of page 165206-8. The correct sentence is: "Also, we identify the minor optical band detected by Lucovsky et al. in their pioneer IR measurements as the LO int. -TO Ga-P In band." This misprint does not change any of the conclusions of the paper.
We propose a simplified version of our 1-bond→2-mode percolation model initially developed for the q ~ 0 phonon properties of the stiff Be-VI bond in (Zn,Be)-chalcogenides, which open the class of random mixed crystals with contrast in the bond stiffness. The simplified version applies to the 'usual' alloys, i.e. made of soft-like bonds only. It is derived from detailed comparison of the Raman responses from the stiff Be-Te bond and the soft Zn-Te one in the pioneer (Zn,Be)Te system. The simplified version is eventually tested on (Ga,In)As whose 1-bond→2-mode behavior in the Ga-As range of the Raman spectra remains a much debated issue. Further, we lay the foundations for a comprehensive re-examination of the puzzling phonon behavior' of the similar (Ga,In)P alloy, by analogy with (Ga,In)As.
Contrary to a broadly accepted assumption we show that random (Ga,In)P is not
an exception with respect to the crude classification of the phonon mode
behavior of random mixed crystals in terms of 1-bond->1-mode systems or
2-bond->1-mode systems, as established from the simple criterion derived by
Elliott et al. [Rev.Mod.Phys. 46, 465 (1974)]. Consistent understanding of the
puzzling Raman/infrared behavior of (Ga,In)P, that has been a subject of
controversy, is achieved via a basic version of our 1-bond->2-mode model. The
Raman/infrared features from (Ga,In)P are accordingly re-assigned, with
considerable change with respect to the previous approaches. Besides, we show
that the idea of two bond lengths per species in alloys, supported by our
1-bond->2-phonon picture, opens an attractive area for the discussion of
spontaneous ordering in GaInP_2, and in mixed crystals in general. The whole
discussion is supported by detailed re-examination of the (Ga,In)P
Raman/infrared data in the literature, full contour modeling of the transverse
and longitudinal optical Raman lineshapes via our phenomenological
1-bond->2-mode model, and first-principles bond length calculations.Comment: 12 pages, 3 figures, submitted to Phys.Rev.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.