No abstract

The habituation to sensory stimuli of different modalities is reduced in migraine patients. However, the habituation to pain has never been evaluated. Our aim was to assess the nociceptive pathway function and the habituation to experimental pain in patients with migraine. Scalp potentials were evoked by CO(2) laser stimulation (laser evoked potentials, LEPs) of the hand and facial skin in 24 patients with migraine without aura (MO), 19 patients with chronic tension-type headache (CTTH), and 28 control subjects (CS). The habituation was studied by measuring the changes of LEP amplitudes across three consecutive repetitions of 30 trials each (the repetitions lasted 5 min and were separated by 5-min intervals). The slope of the regression line between LEP amplitude and number of repetitions was taken as an index of habituation. The LEPs consisted of middle-latency, low-amplitude responses (N1, contralateral temporal region, and P1, frontal region) followed by a late, high-amplitude, negative-positive complex (N2/P2, vertex). The latency and amplitude of these responses were similar in both patients and controls. While CS and CTTH patients showed a significant habituation of the N2/P2 response, in MO patients this LEP component did not develop any habituation at all after face stimulation and showed a significantly lower habituation than in CS after hand stimulation. The habituation index of the vertex N2/P2 complex exceeded the normal limits in 13 out of the 24 MO patients and in none of the 19 CTTH patients (P<0.0001; Fisher's exact test). Moreover, while the N1-P1 amplitude showed a significant habituation in CS after hand stimulation, it did not change across repetitions in MO patients. In conclusion, no functional impairment of the nociceptive pathways, including the trigeminal pathways, was found in either MO or CTTH patients. But patients with migraine had a reduced habituation, which probably reflects an abnormal excitability of the cortical areas involved in pain processing.

Expectation and conditioning are supposed to be the two main psychological mechanisms for inducing a placebo response. Here, we further investigate the effects of both expectation, which was induced by verbal suggestion alone, and conditioning at the level of N1 and N2-P2 components of CO2 laser-evoked potentials (LEPs) and subjective pain reports. Forty-four healthy volunteers were pseudorandomly assigned to one of three experimental groups: Group 1 was tested with verbal suggestion alone, Group 2 was tested with a conditioning procedure, whereby the intensity of painful stimulation was reduced surreptitiously, so as to make the volunteers believe that the treatment was effective, Group 3 was a control group that allowed us to rule out phenomena of sensitization and/or habituation. Pain perception was assessed according to a Numerical Rating Scale (NRS) ranging from 0=no pain sensation to 10=maximum imaginable pain. Both verbal suggestions (Group 1) and conditioning (Group 2) modified the N2-P2 complex, but not the N1 component of LEPs. However, the suggestion-induced LEP changes occurred without subjective perception of pain decrease. Conversely, the N2-P2 amplitude changes that were induced by the conditioning procedure were associated with the subjective perception of pain reduction. Compared to natural history, conditioning produced more robust reductions of LEP amplitudes than verbal suggestions alone. Overall, these findings indicate that prior positive experience plays a key role in maximizing both behavioral and neurophysiological placebo responses, emphasizing that the placebo effect is a learning phenomenon which affects the early central nociceptive processing.

Laser pulses excite superficial free nerve endings innervated by small-myelinated (Adelta) and unmyelinated (C) fibres. Whereas laser-evoked scalp potentials (LEPs) are now reliably used to assess function of the Adelta-fibre nociceptive pathways in patients with peripheral or central lesions, the selective activation of C-fibre receptors and recording of the related brain potentials remain difficult. To investigate trigeminal C-fibre function, we directed laser pulses to the facial skin and studied sensory perception and scalp evoked potentials related to Adelta- or C-fibre activation in healthy humans and patients--one having a bilateral facial palsy, two a trigeminal neuropathy, and two a Wallenberg syndrome. We also measured afferent conduction velocity and, with source analysis, studied the brain generators. Whereas laser pulses of low intensity and small irradiated area elicited pinprick sensations and standard Adelta-LEPs, laser pulses of very-low intensity and large irradiated area elicited warmth sensations and scalp potentials with a latency compatible with C-fibre conduction (negative wave 280 ms, positive wave 380 ms); the estimated conduction velocity was 1.2 m/s. The main waves of the scalp potentials originated from the anterior cingulate gyrus; they were preceded by activity in the opercular region and followed by activity in the insular region. The patient with bilateral facial palsy, who had absent trigeminal-facial reflexes, had normal Adelta- and C-related scalp potentials; the patients with trigeminal neuropathy, characterized by loss of myelinated and sparing of unmyelinated fibres, had absent Adelta- but normal C-related potentials; and the patients with Wallenberg syndrome had absent Adelta- and C-related potentials. We conclude that laser pulses with appropriate characteristics evoke brain potentials related to the selective activation of trigeminal nociceptive Adelta or thermal C fibres. The trigeminal territory yields rewarding LEP findings owing to the high density of thermal receptors and, because the short conduction distance, minimizes the problem of signal dispersion along slow-conducting unmyelinated afferents. The opercular-insular region and the cingulate gyrus are involved in the processing of C-fibre trigeminal inputs. The method we describe may prove useful in patients with lesions affecting the trigeminal thermal pain pathways.