During maximal contractions, the sum of forces exerted by homonymous muscles unilaterally is typically larger than the sum of forces exerted by the same muscles bilaterally. This phenomenon is known as the bilateral deficit (BLD), and it is suggested that this deficit is due to neural inhibition. It remains unclear, however, whether such inhibition is mediated by supraspinal mechanisms or by reflex pathways at the level of spinal cord. To further study the origin of likely neural influences, we tested for the presence of BLD under the condition of reflexive force generation. Force output and integrated electromyogram (iEMG) (quadriceps femoris) were measured in 17 male participants after initiation of the myotatic patellar reflex under unilateral and bilateral conditions. A significant BLD of 9.26 ± 1.19 ( P = 0.004) and 16.76 ± 4.69% ( P = 0.001) was found for force and iEMG, respectively. However, because similar findings were not evident during maximal isometric knee extensions, it is difficult to predict the contribution of a spinal mechanism to the BLD under the condition of maximal voluntary activation.