There is an increasing interest in introducing autonomous (or at least semi-autonomous) working groups into firms. The underlying view of 'cooperative work' is rather euphoric and uncritical. The aim of this research note, therefore, is to confront the often cited advantages for employees with an empirical study of an 'ideal' case. The presented group is ideal in that it features maximal autonomy of the group and maximal involvement of the group members in all the relevant decisions. The results of this investigation are extrapolated for 'normal' working groups in firms. In other words, the aspect examined is that group work may be less beneficial for employees than is often suggested by proponents of group work.
Purpose -The purpose of this paper is to discuss diversity management in the light of Bourdieu's social theory. One question of particular interest is whether diversity management could -at least conceptually -lead to the retention of highly-educated female engineers in their chosen professions in science, engineering and technology. Design/methodology/approach -An explorative empirical study was conducted. In total, 12 female computer scientists in Austria who voluntarily quit their jobs were interviewed with respect to motives, reasons and experiences in their rather male-dominated organizations. Findings -The results show very clearly that diversity management could contribute to the retention of female engineers if changes in the "habitus" are realized.Research limitations/implications -Due to the small study sample, any conclusions are limited in their generality. However, the paper is a contribution to the discussion on how to attract and retain sustainably more women to the fields of science, engineering and technology. Further research on Bourdieu's social theory and its empirical application within the study of organizations is a promising direction for research. Practical implications -The paper elaborates the main features of an inclusive management concept, in particular for organizations in the technology branch. In addition, some insights concerning the motives for women to quit their jobs are highlighted. Social implications -The paper shows that it is insufficient to simply motivate women to choose a career in engineering. To retain women in such sectors, the current gender-biased organizational cultures and structures have first to be changed. Originality/value -Many research contributions exist which have examined the motivation and de-motivation of women to find the fields of engineering and technology attractive; however, there is a lack of relevant studies to examine the reasons why women with a technical/engineering background are motivated to leave their branch after several years. Furthermore, there has been no previous attempt to examine the social theory of Bourdieu in relation to diversity management and its implications for gendered organizations.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.