Recommender Systems (
RecSys
) provide suggestions in many decision-making processes. Given that groups of people can perform many real-world activities (e.g., a group of people attending a conference looking for a place to dine), the need for recommendations for groups has increased. A wide range of Group Recommender Systems (
GRecSys
) has been developed to aggregate individual preferences to group preferences. We analyze
175
studies related to
GRecSys
. Previous works evaluate their systems using different types of groups (sizes and cohesiveness), and most of such works focus on testing their systems using only one type of item, called experience goods (EG). As a consequence, it is hard to get consistent conclusions about the performance of
GRecSys
. We present the aggregation strategies and aggregation functions that
GRecSys
commonly use to aggregate group members’ preferences. This study experimentally compares the performance (i.e., accuracy, ranking quality, and usefulness) using
four
metrics (Hit Ratio, nDCG, Diversity, and Coverage) of
eight
representative
RecSys
for group recommendations on ephemeral groups. Moreover, we use
two
different aggregation strategies,
ten
different aggregation functions, and
two
different types of items on two types of datasets (Experience Goods (EG) and Search Goods (SG)) containing real-life datasets. The results show that the evaluation of
GRecSys
needs to use both EG and SG types of data because the different characteristics of datasets lead to different performance.
GRecSys
using Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) or Neural Collaborative Filtering (NCF) methods work better than others. It is observed that the Average aggregation function is the one that produces better results.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.