Purpose There is little evidence proving the concept of partial weight-bearing to be efficient and feasible. Using insole pressure measurement systems, this study aimed to explore the compliance to prescribed weight-bearing restrictions after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Methods 50 patients after TKA were recruited in a prospective manner. They were advised to limit weight-bearing of the affected limb to 200 N. True load was measured via insole force-sensors on day one after surgery (M1) and before discharge (M2). Compliance to the rehabilitation protocol was the primary outcome parameter. Results At M1 and M2 compliance to the rehabilitation protocol was 0% und 2%, respectively. 84% (M1) and 90% (M2) of patients overloaded the affected limb during every step. The affected limb was loaded with 50% ± 14% (M1) and 57% ± 17% (M2) of body weight. Patients older than 65 loaded the affected limb on average 17% (M1) and 34% (M2) more than their younger counterparts did. This difference was even more pronounced when walking stairs up (49% increase on average) and down (53% increase on average). Conclusion Surgeons must take into consideration that the ability to maintain partial weight-bearing after TKA is highly dependent on the age of the patient and the achievable load reduction is determined by the patient’s body weight.