Both steric and electronic factors of substituted alkynes are known to guide α/β-cyclopentenone regioselectivity in the cobalt-mediated Pauson-Khand reaction (PKR). In synthetic applications of the PKR, the steric factors can often override or render possible electronic effects. This study examined alkyne-dependent electronic regioselectivity of cyclopentenone formation in PKR with norbornene and sterically equivalent, but electronically unsymmetrical, meta- and para-substituted diarylethynyls to unveil the role of electronic effects alone. In agreement with the literature reports, EDG para-substituted aryls, to some extent, favored the cyclopentenone α-regioisomer, while the EWG-substituted aryls correspondingly preferred the β-regioisomer. The cooperation of EGW and EDG in diaryl-substituted alkynes did not lead to any increased regioselectivities that could be expected by a "push-pull" effect. Both EWG and EDG meta-substituted aryls preferred the β-regioisomer, which was demonstrated by 3,5-dimethoxy- and 3,5-bis(trifluoromethyl)-1-phenylethynyls that yielded 1/1.6 and 1/2.0 α/β-regioselectivities, respectively. Theoretically, inspection of Hammett values of α-alkyne carbons gave qualitatively satisfactory prediction for para-substituted aryls but correlated only weakly with meta-substituted effects. Computational investigations at the DFT level revealed a correlation between NBO charges and the regioselectivity. Overall, the results suggest that the polarity of an alkyne, also designated by the relative polarization of aryl α-carbons, dictates the regioselectivity in the absence of steric effects.

Generally judged poor electronic regioselectivity of alkyne insertion in intermolecular Pauson-Khand reaction (PKR) has severely restricted its synthetic applications. In our previous rational study concerning diarylalkynes (Fager-Jokela, E.; Muuronen, M.; Patzschke, M.; Helaja, J. J. Org. Chem. 2012, 77, 9134-9147), both experimental and theoretical results indicated that purely electronic factors, i.e., alkyne polarization via resonance effect, induced the observed modest regioselectivity. In the present work, we substantiate that the alkyne polarization via inductive effect can result notable, synthetically valuable regioselectivity. Computational study at DFT level was performed to disclose the electronic origin of the selectivity. Overall, the NBO charges of alkynes correlated qualitatively with regioisomer outcome. In a detailed computational PKR case study, the obtained Boltzmann distributions of the transition state (TS) populations correlate closely with experimental regioselectivity. Analysis of the TS-structures revealed that weak interactions, e.g., hydrogen bonding and steric repulsion, affect the regioselectivity and can easily override the electronic guidance.

No abstract

Polarization of the alkyne bond dictates the regioselectivity of the reaction.