T otal hip and total knee arthroplasty both provide a considerable improvement in quality of life, but there is no evidence to suggest that one is more successful than the other. We studied 72 patients in a prospective trial before and after total hip or total knee replacement. We recorded scores for disability and distress derived from the Harris hip score and the British Orthopaedic Association knee assessment score, and used them to generate quality of life (QoL) scores using the Rosser Index Matrix immediately before and at one year after surgery.The patients awaiting knee replacement had significantly lower QoL scores than those awaiting hip replacement (p = 0.011). The QoL scores at one year were high and almost identical for both groups (p = 0.46). Further analysis showed that gender and weight were not significant predictors of improvement of QoL scores, but age (p = 0.03) and whether the hip or knee was replaced (p = 0.006) were significant factors.

Purpose Large scale databases that offer a reflection of clinical negligence are rare. By assessing commonly occuring cases of negligence, we hope to highlight areas where pediatric orthopedic care might be improved. One such database is the National Health Service Litigation Authority, which deals with claims brought against all health trusts in England. By collating their data we aimed to highlight areas of commonly occurring clinical negligence and then suggest ways to avoid similar happening again. Method We reviewed all cases pertaining to pediatric orthopedic claims between 1995 to 2006 as provided by the NHSLA. Results Of those considered in our study (341), by far the most common cause of litigation is missed or incorrectly diagnosed injuries/ conditions-accounting for 57% of all cases. 44% of those are upper limb injuries, mainly fractures around the elbow. Misdiagnosed disorders of the hip such as hip dysplasia and SCFE also represent a frequent reason for litigation (11%). Other common causes are poor plaster application and removal (7.3%) and non-surgical site specific errors such as chemical burns from skin prep. Conclusion Although specific to the English system, these findings are likely to mirror that found in other countries. Highlighting these commonly occurring errors, better education of doctors in targeted areas and due care in simple procedures may have significant improvement of child orthopedic care.

No abstract

No abstract

No abstract